When -s is used with third person singular. What's its use in this context?Text in Asterisks in 3rd person singularpast perfect continuous in negative sentencethird person singular verbs in questionsWhich word should I use “which” or “where”?difference between the and a in this context with relative clausepronouns as subjects or objectsThat “was” OR That “is” my birthday weekwh-questions about a subjectSunday being third person singular?Does question word “Who” always require a singular verb?Why past simple not present perfect?
How to draw a Venn diagram for X - (Y intersect Z)?
Pronunciation of "солнце"
How do we know that black holes are spinning?
Why does the speed of sound decrease at high altitudes although the air density decreases?
How can I use expandafter the expand the definition of this control sequence?
Why is belonging not transitive?
Building Truncatable Primes using Nest(List), While, Fold
Why are some files not movable on Windows 10?
Is there any reason to concentrate on the Thunderous Smite spell after using its effects?
What are the advantages and disadvantages of tail wheels that cause modern airplanes to not use them?
Why is my fire extinguisher emptied after one use?
In what sequence should an advanced civilization teach technology to medieval society to maximize rate of adoption?
Why is the car dealer insisting on a loan instead of cash?
Permutations in Disguise
geschafft or geschaffen? which one is past participle of schaffen?
Meaning of Swimming their horses
Importance of the current postdoc advisor's letter in TT job search
How to control the output voltage of a solid state relay
Masking out non-linear shapes on canvas
Impossible Scrabble Words
How can I say "I want to" as a short response, omitting the main verb?
How to be sure services and researches offered by the University are not becoming cases of unfair competition?
What was the motivation for the invention of electric pianos?
Can I travel to European countries with the Irish passport and without destination Visa?
When -s is used with third person singular. What's its use in this context?
Text in Asterisks in 3rd person singularpast perfect continuous in negative sentencethird person singular verbs in questionsWhich word should I use “which” or “where”?difference between the and a in this context with relative clausepronouns as subjects or objectsThat “was” OR That “is” my birthday weekwh-questions about a subjectSunday being third person singular?Does question word “Who” always require a singular verb?Why past simple not present perfect?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty margin-bottom:0;
During a conversation
My friend wrote •shrugs•
Why shrugs not shrug?
She was the one who did it then why third person singular form?
grammar
add a comment
|
During a conversation
My friend wrote •shrugs•
Why shrugs not shrug?
She was the one who did it then why third person singular form?
grammar
add a comment
|
During a conversation
My friend wrote •shrugs•
Why shrugs not shrug?
She was the one who did it then why third person singular form?
grammar
During a conversation
My friend wrote •shrugs•
Why shrugs not shrug?
She was the one who did it then why third person singular form?
grammar
grammar
asked Apr 15 at 10:35
user83680
add a comment
|
add a comment
|
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
It is becoming increasingly common during text messaging to write actions as if they are from a script, for example, words like laughs or shrugs describe an action that the other person is doing but you cannot see over a text message.
TV and movie scripts are often written this way:
BOB
WHY DID YOU WRITE THAT?
JOHN
[SHRUGS]
The tense makes sense in a script because it is a prompt to say what happens. I guess this has just found its way into text-messaging as I have seen it done quite a few times.
It is also possible that your friend tried to send some kind of emoji that is named "shrugs" and you just saw a text representation of it.
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
AstralbeeAstralbee
19.1k21 silver badges61 bronze badges
2
I'm curious, do you have any sources that this is the origin of the practice, or is this a personal theory?
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 11:24
8
@SamBC [rolls eyes]
– Astralbee
Apr 15 at 11:29
1
As to the why, when you look at a chat/sms interface it shows speech bubbles and often includes the users' names for each response in the conversation, similar to a script/screenplay, except for alternating alignment. May I suggest an edit to the conversation to right align John and his response to illustrate this? @SamBC consider self-referentiality :-)
– mcalex
Apr 15 at 15:26
2
I would add that the practice of giving stage directions in the third person is very old. The word exit, for example, and its plural exeunt, is the third person present active indicative singular, meaning he (or she or it) goes out and they go out, respectively.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:31
1
As far as the chat/IM usage, it dates back to some of the earliest chat networks (I've seen 20 plus year old usenet and BBS messages that used it). It was made popular by IRC though, which actually has a shorthand command for formatting a comment to show up like stage directions for the user sending it in the chat log, as pointed out by SamBC's answer.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Apr 15 at 22:25
|
show 1 more comment
Now, this is my best guess, because if you want to know why she did it, you need to ask her. I imagine the answer will be something along the lines of "that's how everyone does it", because it is common, and people don't always know the 'why' for something that's general practice.
However, I would imagine this has to do with the history of online chat. Back in the day when you had IRC, web chats, etc, the way you indicate that you were doing something was to use some prefix - "/me" on IRC, ":" on non-IRC based web or console chats, in my experience - and it would be rendered like so, the first line being what the user typed and the second line being what was produced in chat:
/me waves hello
USERNAME waves hello
Because of this, people got used to writing such actions in the third person, and that pattern has continued even though a lot of modern chat systems don't have such syntax for actions, including even SMS (which now has a chat-like interface on smartphones).
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
SamBCSamBC
20.5k26 silver badges78 bronze badges
Which was also picked up by MMOs, where emotes like/wavewould output "Username waves." This seems much more likely than TV scripts.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:53
@isanae: pretty much any chat with /-commands is derived from IRC, I would say. The other sort of chat that this went through, of course, was MUDs and MOOs and such.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 16:55
Yep, third-person reactions in chat are much older than text messaging and speech bubbles, as the other answer suggests. It's unfortunate the OP has ticked an answer so quickly.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:59
@isanae It always seemed to me that the reason IRC and the like supported this feature is because it resembled stage directions in a script, so the other answer is arguably closer to the underlying cause. In my experience, people were also typing things like "waves hello" and "shrugs" even without using or knowing about the username substitution feature.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:34
@phoog: well, the username still appears by that. It essentially ends up be a description of what has happened, in the third person. The fact of these different interpretations is why I would love to see if anyone has actually tried to figure this out.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 21:58
|
show 3 more comments
I often see this in text/internet convention. Often, the narrative phrases get enclosed by asterisks, as in
johnthecatlover42: when someone violates the treaty of versailles
*inhales* boi
It's like stage direction in theatre, or a sudden temporary shift into a third-person voice. The text, in this case, is your friend telling you that they are shrugging.
There's almost an implied subject in the person that sent the message.
answered Apr 16 at 4:53
user45266user45266
1,5352 silver badges16 bronze badges
add a comment
|
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "481"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/"u003ecc by-sa 4.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fell.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f205547%2fwhen-s-is-used-with-third-person-singular-whats-its-use-in-this-context%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
It is becoming increasingly common during text messaging to write actions as if they are from a script, for example, words like laughs or shrugs describe an action that the other person is doing but you cannot see over a text message.
TV and movie scripts are often written this way:
BOB
WHY DID YOU WRITE THAT?
JOHN
[SHRUGS]
The tense makes sense in a script because it is a prompt to say what happens. I guess this has just found its way into text-messaging as I have seen it done quite a few times.
It is also possible that your friend tried to send some kind of emoji that is named "shrugs" and you just saw a text representation of it.
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
AstralbeeAstralbee
19.1k21 silver badges61 bronze badges
2
I'm curious, do you have any sources that this is the origin of the practice, or is this a personal theory?
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 11:24
8
@SamBC [rolls eyes]
– Astralbee
Apr 15 at 11:29
1
As to the why, when you look at a chat/sms interface it shows speech bubbles and often includes the users' names for each response in the conversation, similar to a script/screenplay, except for alternating alignment. May I suggest an edit to the conversation to right align John and his response to illustrate this? @SamBC consider self-referentiality :-)
– mcalex
Apr 15 at 15:26
2
I would add that the practice of giving stage directions in the third person is very old. The word exit, for example, and its plural exeunt, is the third person present active indicative singular, meaning he (or she or it) goes out and they go out, respectively.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:31
1
As far as the chat/IM usage, it dates back to some of the earliest chat networks (I've seen 20 plus year old usenet and BBS messages that used it). It was made popular by IRC though, which actually has a shorthand command for formatting a comment to show up like stage directions for the user sending it in the chat log, as pointed out by SamBC's answer.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Apr 15 at 22:25
|
show 1 more comment
It is becoming increasingly common during text messaging to write actions as if they are from a script, for example, words like laughs or shrugs describe an action that the other person is doing but you cannot see over a text message.
TV and movie scripts are often written this way:
BOB
WHY DID YOU WRITE THAT?
JOHN
[SHRUGS]
The tense makes sense in a script because it is a prompt to say what happens. I guess this has just found its way into text-messaging as I have seen it done quite a few times.
It is also possible that your friend tried to send some kind of emoji that is named "shrugs" and you just saw a text representation of it.
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
AstralbeeAstralbee
19.1k21 silver badges61 bronze badges
2
I'm curious, do you have any sources that this is the origin of the practice, or is this a personal theory?
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 11:24
8
@SamBC [rolls eyes]
– Astralbee
Apr 15 at 11:29
1
As to the why, when you look at a chat/sms interface it shows speech bubbles and often includes the users' names for each response in the conversation, similar to a script/screenplay, except for alternating alignment. May I suggest an edit to the conversation to right align John and his response to illustrate this? @SamBC consider self-referentiality :-)
– mcalex
Apr 15 at 15:26
2
I would add that the practice of giving stage directions in the third person is very old. The word exit, for example, and its plural exeunt, is the third person present active indicative singular, meaning he (or she or it) goes out and they go out, respectively.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:31
1
As far as the chat/IM usage, it dates back to some of the earliest chat networks (I've seen 20 plus year old usenet and BBS messages that used it). It was made popular by IRC though, which actually has a shorthand command for formatting a comment to show up like stage directions for the user sending it in the chat log, as pointed out by SamBC's answer.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Apr 15 at 22:25
|
show 1 more comment
It is becoming increasingly common during text messaging to write actions as if they are from a script, for example, words like laughs or shrugs describe an action that the other person is doing but you cannot see over a text message.
TV and movie scripts are often written this way:
BOB
WHY DID YOU WRITE THAT?
JOHN
[SHRUGS]
The tense makes sense in a script because it is a prompt to say what happens. I guess this has just found its way into text-messaging as I have seen it done quite a few times.
It is also possible that your friend tried to send some kind of emoji that is named "shrugs" and you just saw a text representation of it.
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
AstralbeeAstralbee
19.1k21 silver badges61 bronze badges
It is becoming increasingly common during text messaging to write actions as if they are from a script, for example, words like laughs or shrugs describe an action that the other person is doing but you cannot see over a text message.
TV and movie scripts are often written this way:
BOB
WHY DID YOU WRITE THAT?
JOHN
[SHRUGS]
The tense makes sense in a script because it is a prompt to say what happens. I guess this has just found its way into text-messaging as I have seen it done quite a few times.
It is also possible that your friend tried to send some kind of emoji that is named "shrugs" and you just saw a text representation of it.
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
AstralbeeAstralbee
19.1k21 silver badges61 bronze badges
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
AstralbeeAstralbee
19.1k21 silver badges61 bronze badges
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
AstralbeeAstralbee
19.1k21 silver badges61 bronze badges
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
AstralbeeAstralbee
19.1k21 silver badges61 bronze badges
19.1k21 silver badges61 bronze badges
2
I'm curious, do you have any sources that this is the origin of the practice, or is this a personal theory?
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 11:24
8
@SamBC [rolls eyes]
– Astralbee
Apr 15 at 11:29
1
As to the why, when you look at a chat/sms interface it shows speech bubbles and often includes the users' names for each response in the conversation, similar to a script/screenplay, except for alternating alignment. May I suggest an edit to the conversation to right align John and his response to illustrate this? @SamBC consider self-referentiality :-)
– mcalex
Apr 15 at 15:26
2
I would add that the practice of giving stage directions in the third person is very old. The word exit, for example, and its plural exeunt, is the third person present active indicative singular, meaning he (or she or it) goes out and they go out, respectively.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:31
1
As far as the chat/IM usage, it dates back to some of the earliest chat networks (I've seen 20 plus year old usenet and BBS messages that used it). It was made popular by IRC though, which actually has a shorthand command for formatting a comment to show up like stage directions for the user sending it in the chat log, as pointed out by SamBC's answer.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Apr 15 at 22:25
|
show 1 more comment
2
I'm curious, do you have any sources that this is the origin of the practice, or is this a personal theory?
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 11:24
8
@SamBC [rolls eyes]
– Astralbee
Apr 15 at 11:29
1
As to the why, when you look at a chat/sms interface it shows speech bubbles and often includes the users' names for each response in the conversation, similar to a script/screenplay, except for alternating alignment. May I suggest an edit to the conversation to right align John and his response to illustrate this? @SamBC consider self-referentiality :-)
– mcalex
Apr 15 at 15:26
2
I would add that the practice of giving stage directions in the third person is very old. The word exit, for example, and its plural exeunt, is the third person present active indicative singular, meaning he (or she or it) goes out and they go out, respectively.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:31
1
As far as the chat/IM usage, it dates back to some of the earliest chat networks (I've seen 20 plus year old usenet and BBS messages that used it). It was made popular by IRC though, which actually has a shorthand command for formatting a comment to show up like stage directions for the user sending it in the chat log, as pointed out by SamBC's answer.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Apr 15 at 22:25
2
2
I'm curious, do you have any sources that this is the origin of the practice, or is this a personal theory?
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 11:24
I'm curious, do you have any sources that this is the origin of the practice, or is this a personal theory?
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 11:24
8
8
@SamBC [rolls eyes]
– Astralbee
Apr 15 at 11:29
@SamBC [rolls eyes]
– Astralbee
Apr 15 at 11:29
1
1
As to the why, when you look at a chat/sms interface it shows speech bubbles and often includes the users' names for each response in the conversation, similar to a script/screenplay, except for alternating alignment. May I suggest an edit to the conversation to right align John and his response to illustrate this? @SamBC consider self-referentiality :-)
– mcalex
Apr 15 at 15:26
As to the why, when you look at a chat/sms interface it shows speech bubbles and often includes the users' names for each response in the conversation, similar to a script/screenplay, except for alternating alignment. May I suggest an edit to the conversation to right align John and his response to illustrate this? @SamBC consider self-referentiality :-)
– mcalex
Apr 15 at 15:26
2
2
I would add that the practice of giving stage directions in the third person is very old. The word exit, for example, and its plural exeunt, is the third person present active indicative singular, meaning he (or she or it) goes out and they go out, respectively.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:31
I would add that the practice of giving stage directions in the third person is very old. The word exit, for example, and its plural exeunt, is the third person present active indicative singular, meaning he (or she or it) goes out and they go out, respectively.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:31
1
1
As far as the chat/IM usage, it dates back to some of the earliest chat networks (I've seen 20 plus year old usenet and BBS messages that used it). It was made popular by IRC though, which actually has a shorthand command for formatting a comment to show up like stage directions for the user sending it in the chat log, as pointed out by SamBC's answer.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Apr 15 at 22:25
As far as the chat/IM usage, it dates back to some of the earliest chat networks (I've seen 20 plus year old usenet and BBS messages that used it). It was made popular by IRC though, which actually has a shorthand command for formatting a comment to show up like stage directions for the user sending it in the chat log, as pointed out by SamBC's answer.
– Austin Hemmelgarn
Apr 15 at 22:25
|
show 1 more comment
Now, this is my best guess, because if you want to know why she did it, you need to ask her. I imagine the answer will be something along the lines of "that's how everyone does it", because it is common, and people don't always know the 'why' for something that's general practice.
However, I would imagine this has to do with the history of online chat. Back in the day when you had IRC, web chats, etc, the way you indicate that you were doing something was to use some prefix - "/me" on IRC, ":" on non-IRC based web or console chats, in my experience - and it would be rendered like so, the first line being what the user typed and the second line being what was produced in chat:
/me waves hello
USERNAME waves hello
Because of this, people got used to writing such actions in the third person, and that pattern has continued even though a lot of modern chat systems don't have such syntax for actions, including even SMS (which now has a chat-like interface on smartphones).
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
SamBCSamBC
20.5k26 silver badges78 bronze badges
Which was also picked up by MMOs, where emotes like/wavewould output "Username waves." This seems much more likely than TV scripts.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:53
@isanae: pretty much any chat with /-commands is derived from IRC, I would say. The other sort of chat that this went through, of course, was MUDs and MOOs and such.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 16:55
Yep, third-person reactions in chat are much older than text messaging and speech bubbles, as the other answer suggests. It's unfortunate the OP has ticked an answer so quickly.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:59
@isanae It always seemed to me that the reason IRC and the like supported this feature is because it resembled stage directions in a script, so the other answer is arguably closer to the underlying cause. In my experience, people were also typing things like "waves hello" and "shrugs" even without using or knowing about the username substitution feature.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:34
@phoog: well, the username still appears by that. It essentially ends up be a description of what has happened, in the third person. The fact of these different interpretations is why I would love to see if anyone has actually tried to figure this out.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 21:58
|
show 3 more comments
Now, this is my best guess, because if you want to know why she did it, you need to ask her. I imagine the answer will be something along the lines of "that's how everyone does it", because it is common, and people don't always know the 'why' for something that's general practice.
However, I would imagine this has to do with the history of online chat. Back in the day when you had IRC, web chats, etc, the way you indicate that you were doing something was to use some prefix - "/me" on IRC, ":" on non-IRC based web or console chats, in my experience - and it would be rendered like so, the first line being what the user typed and the second line being what was produced in chat:
/me waves hello
USERNAME waves hello
Because of this, people got used to writing such actions in the third person, and that pattern has continued even though a lot of modern chat systems don't have such syntax for actions, including even SMS (which now has a chat-like interface on smartphones).
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
SamBCSamBC
20.5k26 silver badges78 bronze badges
Which was also picked up by MMOs, where emotes like/wavewould output "Username waves." This seems much more likely than TV scripts.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:53
@isanae: pretty much any chat with /-commands is derived from IRC, I would say. The other sort of chat that this went through, of course, was MUDs and MOOs and such.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 16:55
Yep, third-person reactions in chat are much older than text messaging and speech bubbles, as the other answer suggests. It's unfortunate the OP has ticked an answer so quickly.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:59
@isanae It always seemed to me that the reason IRC and the like supported this feature is because it resembled stage directions in a script, so the other answer is arguably closer to the underlying cause. In my experience, people were also typing things like "waves hello" and "shrugs" even without using or knowing about the username substitution feature.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:34
@phoog: well, the username still appears by that. It essentially ends up be a description of what has happened, in the third person. The fact of these different interpretations is why I would love to see if anyone has actually tried to figure this out.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 21:58
|
show 3 more comments
Now, this is my best guess, because if you want to know why she did it, you need to ask her. I imagine the answer will be something along the lines of "that's how everyone does it", because it is common, and people don't always know the 'why' for something that's general practice.
However, I would imagine this has to do with the history of online chat. Back in the day when you had IRC, web chats, etc, the way you indicate that you were doing something was to use some prefix - "/me" on IRC, ":" on non-IRC based web or console chats, in my experience - and it would be rendered like so, the first line being what the user typed and the second line being what was produced in chat:
/me waves hello
USERNAME waves hello
Because of this, people got used to writing such actions in the third person, and that pattern has continued even though a lot of modern chat systems don't have such syntax for actions, including even SMS (which now has a chat-like interface on smartphones).
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
SamBCSamBC
20.5k26 silver badges78 bronze badges
Now, this is my best guess, because if you want to know why she did it, you need to ask her. I imagine the answer will be something along the lines of "that's how everyone does it", because it is common, and people don't always know the 'why' for something that's general practice.
However, I would imagine this has to do with the history of online chat. Back in the day when you had IRC, web chats, etc, the way you indicate that you were doing something was to use some prefix - "/me" on IRC, ":" on non-IRC based web or console chats, in my experience - and it would be rendered like so, the first line being what the user typed and the second line being what was produced in chat:
/me waves hello
USERNAME waves hello
Because of this, people got used to writing such actions in the third person, and that pattern has continued even though a lot of modern chat systems don't have such syntax for actions, including even SMS (which now has a chat-like interface on smartphones).
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
SamBCSamBC
20.5k26 silver badges78 bronze badges
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
SamBCSamBC
20.5k26 silver badges78 bronze badges
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
SamBCSamBC
20.5k26 silver badges78 bronze badges
answered Apr 15 at 10:45
SamBCSamBC
20.5k26 silver badges78 bronze badges
20.5k26 silver badges78 bronze badges
Which was also picked up by MMOs, where emotes like/wavewould output "Username waves." This seems much more likely than TV scripts.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:53
@isanae: pretty much any chat with /-commands is derived from IRC, I would say. The other sort of chat that this went through, of course, was MUDs and MOOs and such.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 16:55
Yep, third-person reactions in chat are much older than text messaging and speech bubbles, as the other answer suggests. It's unfortunate the OP has ticked an answer so quickly.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:59
@isanae It always seemed to me that the reason IRC and the like supported this feature is because it resembled stage directions in a script, so the other answer is arguably closer to the underlying cause. In my experience, people were also typing things like "waves hello" and "shrugs" even without using or knowing about the username substitution feature.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:34
@phoog: well, the username still appears by that. It essentially ends up be a description of what has happened, in the third person. The fact of these different interpretations is why I would love to see if anyone has actually tried to figure this out.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 21:58
|
show 3 more comments
Which was also picked up by MMOs, where emotes like/wavewould output "Username waves." This seems much more likely than TV scripts.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:53
@isanae: pretty much any chat with /-commands is derived from IRC, I would say. The other sort of chat that this went through, of course, was MUDs and MOOs and such.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 16:55
Yep, third-person reactions in chat are much older than text messaging and speech bubbles, as the other answer suggests. It's unfortunate the OP has ticked an answer so quickly.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:59
@isanae It always seemed to me that the reason IRC and the like supported this feature is because it resembled stage directions in a script, so the other answer is arguably closer to the underlying cause. In my experience, people were also typing things like "waves hello" and "shrugs" even without using or knowing about the username substitution feature.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:34
@phoog: well, the username still appears by that. It essentially ends up be a description of what has happened, in the third person. The fact of these different interpretations is why I would love to see if anyone has actually tried to figure this out.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 21:58
Which was also picked up by MMOs, where emotes like
/wave would output "Username waves." This seems much more likely than TV scripts.– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:53
Which was also picked up by MMOs, where emotes like
/wave would output "Username waves." This seems much more likely than TV scripts.– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:53
@isanae: pretty much any chat with /-commands is derived from IRC, I would say. The other sort of chat that this went through, of course, was MUDs and MOOs and such.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 16:55
@isanae: pretty much any chat with /-commands is derived from IRC, I would say. The other sort of chat that this went through, of course, was MUDs and MOOs and such.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 16:55
Yep, third-person reactions in chat are much older than text messaging and speech bubbles, as the other answer suggests. It's unfortunate the OP has ticked an answer so quickly.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:59
Yep, third-person reactions in chat are much older than text messaging and speech bubbles, as the other answer suggests. It's unfortunate the OP has ticked an answer so quickly.
– isanae
Apr 15 at 16:59
@isanae It always seemed to me that the reason IRC and the like supported this feature is because it resembled stage directions in a script, so the other answer is arguably closer to the underlying cause. In my experience, people were also typing things like "waves hello" and "shrugs" even without using or knowing about the username substitution feature.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:34
@isanae It always seemed to me that the reason IRC and the like supported this feature is because it resembled stage directions in a script, so the other answer is arguably closer to the underlying cause. In my experience, people were also typing things like "waves hello" and "shrugs" even without using or knowing about the username substitution feature.
– phoog
Apr 15 at 21:34
@phoog: well, the username still appears by that. It essentially ends up be a description of what has happened, in the third person. The fact of these different interpretations is why I would love to see if anyone has actually tried to figure this out.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 21:58
@phoog: well, the username still appears by that. It essentially ends up be a description of what has happened, in the third person. The fact of these different interpretations is why I would love to see if anyone has actually tried to figure this out.
– SamBC
Apr 15 at 21:58
|
show 3 more comments
I often see this in text/internet convention. Often, the narrative phrases get enclosed by asterisks, as in
johnthecatlover42: when someone violates the treaty of versailles
*inhales* boi
It's like stage direction in theatre, or a sudden temporary shift into a third-person voice. The text, in this case, is your friend telling you that they are shrugging.
There's almost an implied subject in the person that sent the message.
answered Apr 16 at 4:53
user45266user45266
1,5352 silver badges16 bronze badges
add a comment
|
I often see this in text/internet convention. Often, the narrative phrases get enclosed by asterisks, as in
johnthecatlover42: when someone violates the treaty of versailles
*inhales* boi
It's like stage direction in theatre, or a sudden temporary shift into a third-person voice. The text, in this case, is your friend telling you that they are shrugging.
There's almost an implied subject in the person that sent the message.
answered Apr 16 at 4:53
user45266user45266
1,5352 silver badges16 bronze badges
add a comment
|
I often see this in text/internet convention. Often, the narrative phrases get enclosed by asterisks, as in
johnthecatlover42: when someone violates the treaty of versailles
*inhales* boi
It's like stage direction in theatre, or a sudden temporary shift into a third-person voice. The text, in this case, is your friend telling you that they are shrugging.
There's almost an implied subject in the person that sent the message.
answered Apr 16 at 4:53
user45266user45266
1,5352 silver badges16 bronze badges
I often see this in text/internet convention. Often, the narrative phrases get enclosed by asterisks, as in
johnthecatlover42: when someone violates the treaty of versailles
*inhales* boi
It's like stage direction in theatre, or a sudden temporary shift into a third-person voice. The text, in this case, is your friend telling you that they are shrugging.
There's almost an implied subject in the person that sent the message.
answered Apr 16 at 4:53
user45266user45266
1,5352 silver badges16 bronze badges
answered Apr 16 at 4:53
user45266user45266
1,5352 silver badges16 bronze badges
answered Apr 16 at 4:53
user45266user45266
1,5352 silver badges16 bronze badges
answered Apr 16 at 4:53
user45266user45266
1,5352 silver badges16 bronze badges
1,5352 silver badges16 bronze badges
add a comment
|
add a comment
|
Thanks for contributing an answer to English Language Learners Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fell.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f205547%2fwhen-s-is-used-with-third-person-singular-whats-its-use-in-this-context%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
