70's/80's story about a high ranking prisoner of war on a prison planetShort story about amnesiac man sent to a prison planet'70s/80s novella: humans foment uprising on POW planet in order to win intergalactic warBook about aliens arriving in an old country; people capture their spaceship and arrive at alien's planet2010s novel series about a supernatural prison inside a tiny cubeChildren's book/story about ghosts allergic to woodBook about a prison sentence carried out by piloting a tank in wars
How can communicating in human language with an unconscious alien species be treated as an attack?
How scammy are cashback sites?
How to Handle Competitive and Blame Culture Within Team
Java OOP Temperature Converter
Creating 123456 in the fewest number of steps
How can there exist a profession consisting of investing others' money?
Fill your bucket with 2020
Would the moon eventually fall into Earth if we reduce its tangential velocity slightly?
What game has this black main menu?
Does Tomb of Levistus overpower (or have any special interaction with) Infernal heritage?
Should I take a side in an external player conflict, or let my game die?
What happens when a photon "dies"?
Overcrowded German trains
Implementation gap in logistics
Tactical illusion combat countermeasures (password system)
What to do if some panel members walk out while I'm being interviewed?
Is it possible to conserve the total kinetic energy of a system, but not its momentum?
What is the relative return point (i.e. the "space it left") of a creature banished by the Banishment spell?
Using a heater and toaster oven trips the breaker. Can an electrician fix this?
Can I rescind my offer of working on weekends after last day?
What is the best way to teach JavaScript functions to middle schoolers?
Should I provide my username and password for my brokerage account to my mortgage lender to verify my assets?
How bad is 1. e4 c5 2. Nf3 d6 3. a3?
Why is the OS obfuscation defense against "It's a Unix system!" not widely implemented?
70's/80's story about a high ranking prisoner of war on a prison planet
Short story about amnesiac man sent to a prison planet'70s/80s novella: humans foment uprising on POW planet in order to win intergalactic warBook about aliens arriving in an old country; people capture their spaceship and arrive at alien's planet2010s novel series about a supernatural prison inside a tiny cubeChildren's book/story about ghosts allergic to woodBook about a prison sentence carried out by piloting a tank in wars
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty
margin-bottom:0;
Basic plot is a galactic war between two factions, but that's backstory not the focus. The protagonist's side is human, I don't recall the enemy as they weren't really the focus of the story as I remember it. They might have been human as well.
The story starts with the protagonist having already been captured and is being sent to the prison planet, which is only populated by prisoners of war. His identity is kept vague to the reader.
He's taken in by the existing prisoners, who have an established hierarchy based on their military rank before capture.
I have a memory of forests and maybe tree houses, with that sort of 'wood based' technology, if you see what I mean. But it's vague and I could be mixing this up with another story.
I think he is given a bit of a hard time initially, and the prisoners have essentially forgotten about the war.
Then at the end of an early chapter it's revealed as a 'twist' that he's actually an Admiral (or some other equally high rank) and is in fact now the highest ranking prisoner on the planet and therefore assumes command. This twist is the thing that stands out most in my mind.
He then knocks the prisoners into shape and I think orchestrates an escape and return to the war.
I remember it as being reminiscent of WW2 PoW stories like Colditz, but it was a long time ago.
Pretty sure I read this as a paperback in the eighties, or maybe early nineties, and at the time I was reading a lot of second hand books that were written in the 60s and 70s. For the longest time I thought it was a Harry Harrison novel, as I read a lot of his work at that time, but having reviewed his work I can't find it. Might be a short story though as I haven't gone through all the possible collections.
Some additional thoughts. In the early stages where his identity is being kept from the reader, I think the character was quite despondent about being captured. After the reveal I think the dynamic was him being a great military leader, and getting the prisoners to remember they are soldiers and fight back lifts him out of his despondency.
When I talk about wood based tech, I basically mean boy scout type stuff as they don't have proper technology or metal in the prison. Hence tree houses, huts, or something like that.
story-identification books
add a comment
|
Basic plot is a galactic war between two factions, but that's backstory not the focus. The protagonist's side is human, I don't recall the enemy as they weren't really the focus of the story as I remember it. They might have been human as well.
The story starts with the protagonist having already been captured and is being sent to the prison planet, which is only populated by prisoners of war. His identity is kept vague to the reader.
He's taken in by the existing prisoners, who have an established hierarchy based on their military rank before capture.
I have a memory of forests and maybe tree houses, with that sort of 'wood based' technology, if you see what I mean. But it's vague and I could be mixing this up with another story.
I think he is given a bit of a hard time initially, and the prisoners have essentially forgotten about the war.
Then at the end of an early chapter it's revealed as a 'twist' that he's actually an Admiral (or some other equally high rank) and is in fact now the highest ranking prisoner on the planet and therefore assumes command. This twist is the thing that stands out most in my mind.
He then knocks the prisoners into shape and I think orchestrates an escape and return to the war.
I remember it as being reminiscent of WW2 PoW stories like Colditz, but it was a long time ago.
Pretty sure I read this as a paperback in the eighties, or maybe early nineties, and at the time I was reading a lot of second hand books that were written in the 60s and 70s. For the longest time I thought it was a Harry Harrison novel, as I read a lot of his work at that time, but having reviewed his work I can't find it. Might be a short story though as I haven't gone through all the possible collections.
Some additional thoughts. In the early stages where his identity is being kept from the reader, I think the character was quite despondent about being captured. After the reveal I think the dynamic was him being a great military leader, and getting the prisoners to remember they are soldiers and fight back lifts him out of his despondency.
When I talk about wood based tech, I basically mean boy scout type stuff as they don't have proper technology or metal in the prison. Hence tree houses, huts, or something like that.
story-identification books
2
This is an excellent description and a nice first post! Just a note that if you have anything else to add you can always edit your own posts.
– TheLethalCarrot
Oct 2 at 15:37
6
My first thought is the Vorkosigan story, "Borders of Infinity" (tor.com/2017/06/05/…), but that was a short story, there's no wood-based technology, and part of the issue is that there is no military structure due to how the Cetagandeans have structured things.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 15:52
1
Thanks, I can see the similarities but pretty sure that isn't it. The thing that sticks in my mind most is the reveal that the protagonist is the highest ranking person ever caught, in fact I think he might even have been 'famous' and there was some shock amongst the prisoners when they realise who he is. That doesn't seem to have been a feature of Borders of Infinity from the synopsis.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 16:01
@TPO: No. While Admiral Naismith (also Lord Vorkosigan in his birth persona) was indeed technically an extremely highly-ranked individual (although his rank was self-assigned, long story), he doesn't reveal his identity to the others until near the end of the story.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 16:21
This is not the right answer, but a similar book (and an excellent read) isA Planet Called Treason
by Orson Scott Card. It is also his first book, I believe.
– BlackThorn
Oct 3 at 16:11
add a comment
|
Basic plot is a galactic war between two factions, but that's backstory not the focus. The protagonist's side is human, I don't recall the enemy as they weren't really the focus of the story as I remember it. They might have been human as well.
The story starts with the protagonist having already been captured and is being sent to the prison planet, which is only populated by prisoners of war. His identity is kept vague to the reader.
He's taken in by the existing prisoners, who have an established hierarchy based on their military rank before capture.
I have a memory of forests and maybe tree houses, with that sort of 'wood based' technology, if you see what I mean. But it's vague and I could be mixing this up with another story.
I think he is given a bit of a hard time initially, and the prisoners have essentially forgotten about the war.
Then at the end of an early chapter it's revealed as a 'twist' that he's actually an Admiral (or some other equally high rank) and is in fact now the highest ranking prisoner on the planet and therefore assumes command. This twist is the thing that stands out most in my mind.
He then knocks the prisoners into shape and I think orchestrates an escape and return to the war.
I remember it as being reminiscent of WW2 PoW stories like Colditz, but it was a long time ago.
Pretty sure I read this as a paperback in the eighties, or maybe early nineties, and at the time I was reading a lot of second hand books that were written in the 60s and 70s. For the longest time I thought it was a Harry Harrison novel, as I read a lot of his work at that time, but having reviewed his work I can't find it. Might be a short story though as I haven't gone through all the possible collections.
Some additional thoughts. In the early stages where his identity is being kept from the reader, I think the character was quite despondent about being captured. After the reveal I think the dynamic was him being a great military leader, and getting the prisoners to remember they are soldiers and fight back lifts him out of his despondency.
When I talk about wood based tech, I basically mean boy scout type stuff as they don't have proper technology or metal in the prison. Hence tree houses, huts, or something like that.
story-identification books
Basic plot is a galactic war between two factions, but that's backstory not the focus. The protagonist's side is human, I don't recall the enemy as they weren't really the focus of the story as I remember it. They might have been human as well.
The story starts with the protagonist having already been captured and is being sent to the prison planet, which is only populated by prisoners of war. His identity is kept vague to the reader.
He's taken in by the existing prisoners, who have an established hierarchy based on their military rank before capture.
I have a memory of forests and maybe tree houses, with that sort of 'wood based' technology, if you see what I mean. But it's vague and I could be mixing this up with another story.
I think he is given a bit of a hard time initially, and the prisoners have essentially forgotten about the war.
Then at the end of an early chapter it's revealed as a 'twist' that he's actually an Admiral (or some other equally high rank) and is in fact now the highest ranking prisoner on the planet and therefore assumes command. This twist is the thing that stands out most in my mind.
He then knocks the prisoners into shape and I think orchestrates an escape and return to the war.
I remember it as being reminiscent of WW2 PoW stories like Colditz, but it was a long time ago.
Pretty sure I read this as a paperback in the eighties, or maybe early nineties, and at the time I was reading a lot of second hand books that were written in the 60s and 70s. For the longest time I thought it was a Harry Harrison novel, as I read a lot of his work at that time, but having reviewed his work I can't find it. Might be a short story though as I haven't gone through all the possible collections.
Some additional thoughts. In the early stages where his identity is being kept from the reader, I think the character was quite despondent about being captured. After the reveal I think the dynamic was him being a great military leader, and getting the prisoners to remember they are soldiers and fight back lifts him out of his despondency.
When I talk about wood based tech, I basically mean boy scout type stuff as they don't have proper technology or metal in the prison. Hence tree houses, huts, or something like that.
story-identification books
story-identification books
edited Oct 2 at 16:08
TPO
asked Oct 2 at 15:32
TPOTPO
2131 silver badge7 bronze badges
2131 silver badge7 bronze badges
2
This is an excellent description and a nice first post! Just a note that if you have anything else to add you can always edit your own posts.
– TheLethalCarrot
Oct 2 at 15:37
6
My first thought is the Vorkosigan story, "Borders of Infinity" (tor.com/2017/06/05/…), but that was a short story, there's no wood-based technology, and part of the issue is that there is no military structure due to how the Cetagandeans have structured things.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 15:52
1
Thanks, I can see the similarities but pretty sure that isn't it. The thing that sticks in my mind most is the reveal that the protagonist is the highest ranking person ever caught, in fact I think he might even have been 'famous' and there was some shock amongst the prisoners when they realise who he is. That doesn't seem to have been a feature of Borders of Infinity from the synopsis.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 16:01
@TPO: No. While Admiral Naismith (also Lord Vorkosigan in his birth persona) was indeed technically an extremely highly-ranked individual (although his rank was self-assigned, long story), he doesn't reveal his identity to the others until near the end of the story.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 16:21
This is not the right answer, but a similar book (and an excellent read) isA Planet Called Treason
by Orson Scott Card. It is also his first book, I believe.
– BlackThorn
Oct 3 at 16:11
add a comment
|
2
This is an excellent description and a nice first post! Just a note that if you have anything else to add you can always edit your own posts.
– TheLethalCarrot
Oct 2 at 15:37
6
My first thought is the Vorkosigan story, "Borders of Infinity" (tor.com/2017/06/05/…), but that was a short story, there's no wood-based technology, and part of the issue is that there is no military structure due to how the Cetagandeans have structured things.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 15:52
1
Thanks, I can see the similarities but pretty sure that isn't it. The thing that sticks in my mind most is the reveal that the protagonist is the highest ranking person ever caught, in fact I think he might even have been 'famous' and there was some shock amongst the prisoners when they realise who he is. That doesn't seem to have been a feature of Borders of Infinity from the synopsis.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 16:01
@TPO: No. While Admiral Naismith (also Lord Vorkosigan in his birth persona) was indeed technically an extremely highly-ranked individual (although his rank was self-assigned, long story), he doesn't reveal his identity to the others until near the end of the story.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 16:21
This is not the right answer, but a similar book (and an excellent read) isA Planet Called Treason
by Orson Scott Card. It is also his first book, I believe.
– BlackThorn
Oct 3 at 16:11
2
2
This is an excellent description and a nice first post! Just a note that if you have anything else to add you can always edit your own posts.
– TheLethalCarrot
Oct 2 at 15:37
This is an excellent description and a nice first post! Just a note that if you have anything else to add you can always edit your own posts.
– TheLethalCarrot
Oct 2 at 15:37
6
6
My first thought is the Vorkosigan story, "Borders of Infinity" (tor.com/2017/06/05/…), but that was a short story, there's no wood-based technology, and part of the issue is that there is no military structure due to how the Cetagandeans have structured things.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 15:52
My first thought is the Vorkosigan story, "Borders of Infinity" (tor.com/2017/06/05/…), but that was a short story, there's no wood-based technology, and part of the issue is that there is no military structure due to how the Cetagandeans have structured things.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 15:52
1
1
Thanks, I can see the similarities but pretty sure that isn't it. The thing that sticks in my mind most is the reveal that the protagonist is the highest ranking person ever caught, in fact I think he might even have been 'famous' and there was some shock amongst the prisoners when they realise who he is. That doesn't seem to have been a feature of Borders of Infinity from the synopsis.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 16:01
Thanks, I can see the similarities but pretty sure that isn't it. The thing that sticks in my mind most is the reveal that the protagonist is the highest ranking person ever caught, in fact I think he might even have been 'famous' and there was some shock amongst the prisoners when they realise who he is. That doesn't seem to have been a feature of Borders of Infinity from the synopsis.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 16:01
@TPO: No. While Admiral Naismith (also Lord Vorkosigan in his birth persona) was indeed technically an extremely highly-ranked individual (although his rank was self-assigned, long story), he doesn't reveal his identity to the others until near the end of the story.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 16:21
@TPO: No. While Admiral Naismith (also Lord Vorkosigan in his birth persona) was indeed technically an extremely highly-ranked individual (although his rank was self-assigned, long story), he doesn't reveal his identity to the others until near the end of the story.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 16:21
This is not the right answer, but a similar book (and an excellent read) is
A Planet Called Treason
by Orson Scott Card. It is also his first book, I believe.– BlackThorn
Oct 3 at 16:11
This is not the right answer, but a similar book (and an excellent read) is
A Planet Called Treason
by Orson Scott Card. It is also his first book, I believe.– BlackThorn
Oct 3 at 16:11
add a comment
|
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
Possibly The Escape Orbit by James White (1965)
Here is a cover from the original 1965 Paperback
And the 1983 reissue which I remember
Basic plot is a galactic war between two factions
The War is between Humans and chlorine-breathing Bugs.
I have a memory of forests and maybe tree houses, with that sort of 'wood based' technology, if you see what I mean.
The prisoners are given just enough equipment to establish a primitive agrarian way of life
the prisoners have essentially forgotten about the war.
The war has lasted almost a century, and the society on the planet has devolved into 2 factions. "The Civilians" - who have been there a long time and want to forget about the war and move on with colonizing the planet. And "The Committee" - who believes it is the duty of every military person to plot escape. They have been working on a "plan" for many many years, but it just never seemed to be the right time to activate it.
Then at the end of an early chapter it's revealed as a 'twist' that he's actually an Admiral (or some other equally high rank)
The Protagonist is not just another captain, as the other prisoners assumed, but rather a Sector Marshal.
2
This could be it. A quick google says this was called “Open Prison” in the UK, and the cover on Amazon (an oddly coloured lander ship) looks familiar. I thought the title had the word ‘Prison’ in it, and the rank of ‘Sector Marshall’ definitely rings a bell. I’ll get a copy from somewhere and see. Thanks for hopefully solving something that’s been bugging me for years!
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:50
The “By the author of Star Surgeon” might also explain the association in my mind with Harry Harrison, as I have his book “Spaceship Medic” and for some reason always linked that with this mystery book.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:55
2
Wowza! The non-human on white-background cover of The Escape Orbit at top bears no small resemblance to the the Fithp of Footfall!
– Lexible
Oct 3 at 4:37
add a comment
|
This reminds me of Revenge of the Damned, one of the Sten series by Alan Cole and Chris Bunch. The story starts in a POW camp on a prison world. The enemy are the Tahn, human but not part of the Empire the Sten serves. Sten was recorded as a prisoner under another name ("Horace" something, don't recall the last name) because his friend Alex had switched his dog tags as their ship lost power and and enemy started to pour in through the many rents in the hull (end of the previous book, Fleet of the Damned). These stories were heavily styled after WWII fictionalizations -- Fleet after the loss of the Philippines near the beginning of the war, and Fate after the German prison camp system, specifically harking back to Colditz.
You have the rest of it -- Sten winds up, not commanding the prisoners in the Colditz analog, but as "Big X", in charge of coordinating all escape attempts, then (because of his background as a spy, as well as all prisoners having been trained in how to be bad prisoners) winds up running a lot of operations from inside the prison before the final escape. These books (nine in the series, as I recall -- don't have my bookshelf where I can see it at the moment) came out in the early to late 1980s, and are well worth rereading (still available in ebook form, at least).
1
Unless it was renamed, the book after "Fleet of the Damned" was "Revenge of the Damned" 8 books in the series, One of my favorite series. But its been years since I last read it.
– NJohnny
Oct 2 at 18:10
2
You are correct, thanks. I've probably read the series half a dozen times, most recently a few months before I got a Kindle.
– Zeiss Ikon
Oct 2 at 18:15
add a comment
|
While it is probably not the book you're looking for due to the year it was released in (1998), Echoes of Honor is the first book that came to my mind.
The protagonist's name is similar to the person you recall as a possible author (Honor Harrington ~ Henry Harrison); the main character (MC)'s death is heavily implied in the first chapters; the prisoners don't immediately recognize the MC's identity; she is revealed to be the highest ranking officer on the prison planet where the majority of the action takes place; and she orchestrates a rebellion and an escape.
There are two factions: the Star Kingdom of Manticore and the People's Republic of Haven. There is, however, no wood weaponry I can recall.
This is an informative answer. You could improve it further by adding quotations from Echoes of Honor to back up your statements. If this is the work that is being looked for, it will help TPO to recognize it as well as creating a firm basis for discussion.
– Invisible Trihedron
Oct 3 at 21:24
add a comment
|
Your Answer
StackExchange.ready(function()
var channelOptions =
tags: "".split(" "),
id: "186"
;
initTagRenderer("".split(" "), "".split(" "), channelOptions);
StackExchange.using("externalEditor", function()
// Have to fire editor after snippets, if snippets enabled
if (StackExchange.settings.snippets.snippetsEnabled)
StackExchange.using("snippets", function()
createEditor();
);
else
createEditor();
);
function createEditor()
StackExchange.prepareEditor(
heartbeatType: 'answer',
autoActivateHeartbeat: false,
convertImagesToLinks: false,
noModals: true,
showLowRepImageUploadWarning: true,
reputationToPostImages: null,
bindNavPrevention: true,
postfix: "",
imageUploader:
brandingHtml: "Powered by u003ca class="icon-imgur-white" href="https://imgur.com/"u003eu003c/au003e",
contentPolicyHtml: "User contributions licensed under u003ca href="https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/"u003ecc by-sa 4.0 with attribution requiredu003c/au003e u003ca href="https://stackoverflow.com/legal/content-policy"u003e(content policy)u003c/au003e",
allowUrls: true
,
noCode: true, onDemand: true,
discardSelector: ".discard-answer"
,immediatelyShowMarkdownHelp:true
);
);
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f220947%2f70s-80s-story-about-a-high-ranking-prisoner-of-war-on-a-prison-planet%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
Possibly The Escape Orbit by James White (1965)
Here is a cover from the original 1965 Paperback
And the 1983 reissue which I remember
Basic plot is a galactic war between two factions
The War is between Humans and chlorine-breathing Bugs.
I have a memory of forests and maybe tree houses, with that sort of 'wood based' technology, if you see what I mean.
The prisoners are given just enough equipment to establish a primitive agrarian way of life
the prisoners have essentially forgotten about the war.
The war has lasted almost a century, and the society on the planet has devolved into 2 factions. "The Civilians" - who have been there a long time and want to forget about the war and move on with colonizing the planet. And "The Committee" - who believes it is the duty of every military person to plot escape. They have been working on a "plan" for many many years, but it just never seemed to be the right time to activate it.
Then at the end of an early chapter it's revealed as a 'twist' that he's actually an Admiral (or some other equally high rank)
The Protagonist is not just another captain, as the other prisoners assumed, but rather a Sector Marshal.
2
This could be it. A quick google says this was called “Open Prison” in the UK, and the cover on Amazon (an oddly coloured lander ship) looks familiar. I thought the title had the word ‘Prison’ in it, and the rank of ‘Sector Marshall’ definitely rings a bell. I’ll get a copy from somewhere and see. Thanks for hopefully solving something that’s been bugging me for years!
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:50
The “By the author of Star Surgeon” might also explain the association in my mind with Harry Harrison, as I have his book “Spaceship Medic” and for some reason always linked that with this mystery book.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:55
2
Wowza! The non-human on white-background cover of The Escape Orbit at top bears no small resemblance to the the Fithp of Footfall!
– Lexible
Oct 3 at 4:37
add a comment
|
Possibly The Escape Orbit by James White (1965)
Here is a cover from the original 1965 Paperback
And the 1983 reissue which I remember
Basic plot is a galactic war between two factions
The War is between Humans and chlorine-breathing Bugs.
I have a memory of forests and maybe tree houses, with that sort of 'wood based' technology, if you see what I mean.
The prisoners are given just enough equipment to establish a primitive agrarian way of life
the prisoners have essentially forgotten about the war.
The war has lasted almost a century, and the society on the planet has devolved into 2 factions. "The Civilians" - who have been there a long time and want to forget about the war and move on with colonizing the planet. And "The Committee" - who believes it is the duty of every military person to plot escape. They have been working on a "plan" for many many years, but it just never seemed to be the right time to activate it.
Then at the end of an early chapter it's revealed as a 'twist' that he's actually an Admiral (or some other equally high rank)
The Protagonist is not just another captain, as the other prisoners assumed, but rather a Sector Marshal.
2
This could be it. A quick google says this was called “Open Prison” in the UK, and the cover on Amazon (an oddly coloured lander ship) looks familiar. I thought the title had the word ‘Prison’ in it, and the rank of ‘Sector Marshall’ definitely rings a bell. I’ll get a copy from somewhere and see. Thanks for hopefully solving something that’s been bugging me for years!
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:50
The “By the author of Star Surgeon” might also explain the association in my mind with Harry Harrison, as I have his book “Spaceship Medic” and for some reason always linked that with this mystery book.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:55
2
Wowza! The non-human on white-background cover of The Escape Orbit at top bears no small resemblance to the the Fithp of Footfall!
– Lexible
Oct 3 at 4:37
add a comment
|
Possibly The Escape Orbit by James White (1965)
Here is a cover from the original 1965 Paperback
And the 1983 reissue which I remember
Basic plot is a galactic war between two factions
The War is between Humans and chlorine-breathing Bugs.
I have a memory of forests and maybe tree houses, with that sort of 'wood based' technology, if you see what I mean.
The prisoners are given just enough equipment to establish a primitive agrarian way of life
the prisoners have essentially forgotten about the war.
The war has lasted almost a century, and the society on the planet has devolved into 2 factions. "The Civilians" - who have been there a long time and want to forget about the war and move on with colonizing the planet. And "The Committee" - who believes it is the duty of every military person to plot escape. They have been working on a "plan" for many many years, but it just never seemed to be the right time to activate it.
Then at the end of an early chapter it's revealed as a 'twist' that he's actually an Admiral (or some other equally high rank)
The Protagonist is not just another captain, as the other prisoners assumed, but rather a Sector Marshal.
Possibly The Escape Orbit by James White (1965)
Here is a cover from the original 1965 Paperback
And the 1983 reissue which I remember
Basic plot is a galactic war between two factions
The War is between Humans and chlorine-breathing Bugs.
I have a memory of forests and maybe tree houses, with that sort of 'wood based' technology, if you see what I mean.
The prisoners are given just enough equipment to establish a primitive agrarian way of life
the prisoners have essentially forgotten about the war.
The war has lasted almost a century, and the society on the planet has devolved into 2 factions. "The Civilians" - who have been there a long time and want to forget about the war and move on with colonizing the planet. And "The Committee" - who believes it is the duty of every military person to plot escape. They have been working on a "plan" for many many years, but it just never seemed to be the right time to activate it.
Then at the end of an early chapter it's revealed as a 'twist' that he's actually an Admiral (or some other equally high rank)
The Protagonist is not just another captain, as the other prisoners assumed, but rather a Sector Marshal.
edited Oct 2 at 17:38
answered Oct 2 at 17:31
NJohnnyNJohnny
4,21011 silver badges37 bronze badges
4,21011 silver badges37 bronze badges
2
This could be it. A quick google says this was called “Open Prison” in the UK, and the cover on Amazon (an oddly coloured lander ship) looks familiar. I thought the title had the word ‘Prison’ in it, and the rank of ‘Sector Marshall’ definitely rings a bell. I’ll get a copy from somewhere and see. Thanks for hopefully solving something that’s been bugging me for years!
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:50
The “By the author of Star Surgeon” might also explain the association in my mind with Harry Harrison, as I have his book “Spaceship Medic” and for some reason always linked that with this mystery book.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:55
2
Wowza! The non-human on white-background cover of The Escape Orbit at top bears no small resemblance to the the Fithp of Footfall!
– Lexible
Oct 3 at 4:37
add a comment
|
2
This could be it. A quick google says this was called “Open Prison” in the UK, and the cover on Amazon (an oddly coloured lander ship) looks familiar. I thought the title had the word ‘Prison’ in it, and the rank of ‘Sector Marshall’ definitely rings a bell. I’ll get a copy from somewhere and see. Thanks for hopefully solving something that’s been bugging me for years!
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:50
The “By the author of Star Surgeon” might also explain the association in my mind with Harry Harrison, as I have his book “Spaceship Medic” and for some reason always linked that with this mystery book.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:55
2
Wowza! The non-human on white-background cover of The Escape Orbit at top bears no small resemblance to the the Fithp of Footfall!
– Lexible
Oct 3 at 4:37
2
2
This could be it. A quick google says this was called “Open Prison” in the UK, and the cover on Amazon (an oddly coloured lander ship) looks familiar. I thought the title had the word ‘Prison’ in it, and the rank of ‘Sector Marshall’ definitely rings a bell. I’ll get a copy from somewhere and see. Thanks for hopefully solving something that’s been bugging me for years!
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:50
This could be it. A quick google says this was called “Open Prison” in the UK, and the cover on Amazon (an oddly coloured lander ship) looks familiar. I thought the title had the word ‘Prison’ in it, and the rank of ‘Sector Marshall’ definitely rings a bell. I’ll get a copy from somewhere and see. Thanks for hopefully solving something that’s been bugging me for years!
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:50
The “By the author of Star Surgeon” might also explain the association in my mind with Harry Harrison, as I have his book “Spaceship Medic” and for some reason always linked that with this mystery book.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:55
The “By the author of Star Surgeon” might also explain the association in my mind with Harry Harrison, as I have his book “Spaceship Medic” and for some reason always linked that with this mystery book.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 21:55
2
2
Wowza! The non-human on white-background cover of The Escape Orbit at top bears no small resemblance to the the Fithp of Footfall!
– Lexible
Oct 3 at 4:37
Wowza! The non-human on white-background cover of The Escape Orbit at top bears no small resemblance to the the Fithp of Footfall!
– Lexible
Oct 3 at 4:37
add a comment
|
This reminds me of Revenge of the Damned, one of the Sten series by Alan Cole and Chris Bunch. The story starts in a POW camp on a prison world. The enemy are the Tahn, human but not part of the Empire the Sten serves. Sten was recorded as a prisoner under another name ("Horace" something, don't recall the last name) because his friend Alex had switched his dog tags as their ship lost power and and enemy started to pour in through the many rents in the hull (end of the previous book, Fleet of the Damned). These stories were heavily styled after WWII fictionalizations -- Fleet after the loss of the Philippines near the beginning of the war, and Fate after the German prison camp system, specifically harking back to Colditz.
You have the rest of it -- Sten winds up, not commanding the prisoners in the Colditz analog, but as "Big X", in charge of coordinating all escape attempts, then (because of his background as a spy, as well as all prisoners having been trained in how to be bad prisoners) winds up running a lot of operations from inside the prison before the final escape. These books (nine in the series, as I recall -- don't have my bookshelf where I can see it at the moment) came out in the early to late 1980s, and are well worth rereading (still available in ebook form, at least).
1
Unless it was renamed, the book after "Fleet of the Damned" was "Revenge of the Damned" 8 books in the series, One of my favorite series. But its been years since I last read it.
– NJohnny
Oct 2 at 18:10
2
You are correct, thanks. I've probably read the series half a dozen times, most recently a few months before I got a Kindle.
– Zeiss Ikon
Oct 2 at 18:15
add a comment
|
This reminds me of Revenge of the Damned, one of the Sten series by Alan Cole and Chris Bunch. The story starts in a POW camp on a prison world. The enemy are the Tahn, human but not part of the Empire the Sten serves. Sten was recorded as a prisoner under another name ("Horace" something, don't recall the last name) because his friend Alex had switched his dog tags as their ship lost power and and enemy started to pour in through the many rents in the hull (end of the previous book, Fleet of the Damned). These stories were heavily styled after WWII fictionalizations -- Fleet after the loss of the Philippines near the beginning of the war, and Fate after the German prison camp system, specifically harking back to Colditz.
You have the rest of it -- Sten winds up, not commanding the prisoners in the Colditz analog, but as "Big X", in charge of coordinating all escape attempts, then (because of his background as a spy, as well as all prisoners having been trained in how to be bad prisoners) winds up running a lot of operations from inside the prison before the final escape. These books (nine in the series, as I recall -- don't have my bookshelf where I can see it at the moment) came out in the early to late 1980s, and are well worth rereading (still available in ebook form, at least).
1
Unless it was renamed, the book after "Fleet of the Damned" was "Revenge of the Damned" 8 books in the series, One of my favorite series. But its been years since I last read it.
– NJohnny
Oct 2 at 18:10
2
You are correct, thanks. I've probably read the series half a dozen times, most recently a few months before I got a Kindle.
– Zeiss Ikon
Oct 2 at 18:15
add a comment
|
This reminds me of Revenge of the Damned, one of the Sten series by Alan Cole and Chris Bunch. The story starts in a POW camp on a prison world. The enemy are the Tahn, human but not part of the Empire the Sten serves. Sten was recorded as a prisoner under another name ("Horace" something, don't recall the last name) because his friend Alex had switched his dog tags as their ship lost power and and enemy started to pour in through the many rents in the hull (end of the previous book, Fleet of the Damned). These stories were heavily styled after WWII fictionalizations -- Fleet after the loss of the Philippines near the beginning of the war, and Fate after the German prison camp system, specifically harking back to Colditz.
You have the rest of it -- Sten winds up, not commanding the prisoners in the Colditz analog, but as "Big X", in charge of coordinating all escape attempts, then (because of his background as a spy, as well as all prisoners having been trained in how to be bad prisoners) winds up running a lot of operations from inside the prison before the final escape. These books (nine in the series, as I recall -- don't have my bookshelf where I can see it at the moment) came out in the early to late 1980s, and are well worth rereading (still available in ebook form, at least).
This reminds me of Revenge of the Damned, one of the Sten series by Alan Cole and Chris Bunch. The story starts in a POW camp on a prison world. The enemy are the Tahn, human but not part of the Empire the Sten serves. Sten was recorded as a prisoner under another name ("Horace" something, don't recall the last name) because his friend Alex had switched his dog tags as their ship lost power and and enemy started to pour in through the many rents in the hull (end of the previous book, Fleet of the Damned). These stories were heavily styled after WWII fictionalizations -- Fleet after the loss of the Philippines near the beginning of the war, and Fate after the German prison camp system, specifically harking back to Colditz.
You have the rest of it -- Sten winds up, not commanding the prisoners in the Colditz analog, but as "Big X", in charge of coordinating all escape attempts, then (because of his background as a spy, as well as all prisoners having been trained in how to be bad prisoners) winds up running a lot of operations from inside the prison before the final escape. These books (nine in the series, as I recall -- don't have my bookshelf where I can see it at the moment) came out in the early to late 1980s, and are well worth rereading (still available in ebook form, at least).
edited Oct 2 at 18:14
answered Oct 2 at 18:01
Zeiss IkonZeiss Ikon
12.2k1 gold badge22 silver badges64 bronze badges
12.2k1 gold badge22 silver badges64 bronze badges
1
Unless it was renamed, the book after "Fleet of the Damned" was "Revenge of the Damned" 8 books in the series, One of my favorite series. But its been years since I last read it.
– NJohnny
Oct 2 at 18:10
2
You are correct, thanks. I've probably read the series half a dozen times, most recently a few months before I got a Kindle.
– Zeiss Ikon
Oct 2 at 18:15
add a comment
|
1
Unless it was renamed, the book after "Fleet of the Damned" was "Revenge of the Damned" 8 books in the series, One of my favorite series. But its been years since I last read it.
– NJohnny
Oct 2 at 18:10
2
You are correct, thanks. I've probably read the series half a dozen times, most recently a few months before I got a Kindle.
– Zeiss Ikon
Oct 2 at 18:15
1
1
Unless it was renamed, the book after "Fleet of the Damned" was "Revenge of the Damned" 8 books in the series, One of my favorite series. But its been years since I last read it.
– NJohnny
Oct 2 at 18:10
Unless it was renamed, the book after "Fleet of the Damned" was "Revenge of the Damned" 8 books in the series, One of my favorite series. But its been years since I last read it.
– NJohnny
Oct 2 at 18:10
2
2
You are correct, thanks. I've probably read the series half a dozen times, most recently a few months before I got a Kindle.
– Zeiss Ikon
Oct 2 at 18:15
You are correct, thanks. I've probably read the series half a dozen times, most recently a few months before I got a Kindle.
– Zeiss Ikon
Oct 2 at 18:15
add a comment
|
While it is probably not the book you're looking for due to the year it was released in (1998), Echoes of Honor is the first book that came to my mind.
The protagonist's name is similar to the person you recall as a possible author (Honor Harrington ~ Henry Harrison); the main character (MC)'s death is heavily implied in the first chapters; the prisoners don't immediately recognize the MC's identity; she is revealed to be the highest ranking officer on the prison planet where the majority of the action takes place; and she orchestrates a rebellion and an escape.
There are two factions: the Star Kingdom of Manticore and the People's Republic of Haven. There is, however, no wood weaponry I can recall.
This is an informative answer. You could improve it further by adding quotations from Echoes of Honor to back up your statements. If this is the work that is being looked for, it will help TPO to recognize it as well as creating a firm basis for discussion.
– Invisible Trihedron
Oct 3 at 21:24
add a comment
|
While it is probably not the book you're looking for due to the year it was released in (1998), Echoes of Honor is the first book that came to my mind.
The protagonist's name is similar to the person you recall as a possible author (Honor Harrington ~ Henry Harrison); the main character (MC)'s death is heavily implied in the first chapters; the prisoners don't immediately recognize the MC's identity; she is revealed to be the highest ranking officer on the prison planet where the majority of the action takes place; and she orchestrates a rebellion and an escape.
There are two factions: the Star Kingdom of Manticore and the People's Republic of Haven. There is, however, no wood weaponry I can recall.
This is an informative answer. You could improve it further by adding quotations from Echoes of Honor to back up your statements. If this is the work that is being looked for, it will help TPO to recognize it as well as creating a firm basis for discussion.
– Invisible Trihedron
Oct 3 at 21:24
add a comment
|
While it is probably not the book you're looking for due to the year it was released in (1998), Echoes of Honor is the first book that came to my mind.
The protagonist's name is similar to the person you recall as a possible author (Honor Harrington ~ Henry Harrison); the main character (MC)'s death is heavily implied in the first chapters; the prisoners don't immediately recognize the MC's identity; she is revealed to be the highest ranking officer on the prison planet where the majority of the action takes place; and she orchestrates a rebellion and an escape.
There are two factions: the Star Kingdom of Manticore and the People's Republic of Haven. There is, however, no wood weaponry I can recall.
While it is probably not the book you're looking for due to the year it was released in (1998), Echoes of Honor is the first book that came to my mind.
The protagonist's name is similar to the person you recall as a possible author (Honor Harrington ~ Henry Harrison); the main character (MC)'s death is heavily implied in the first chapters; the prisoners don't immediately recognize the MC's identity; she is revealed to be the highest ranking officer on the prison planet where the majority of the action takes place; and she orchestrates a rebellion and an escape.
There are two factions: the Star Kingdom of Manticore and the People's Republic of Haven. There is, however, no wood weaponry I can recall.
edited Oct 3 at 21:21
Invisible Trihedron
8,2301 gold badge23 silver badges65 bronze badges
8,2301 gold badge23 silver badges65 bronze badges
answered Oct 3 at 20:42
Syfer PolskiSyfer Polski
1211 bronze badge
1211 bronze badge
This is an informative answer. You could improve it further by adding quotations from Echoes of Honor to back up your statements. If this is the work that is being looked for, it will help TPO to recognize it as well as creating a firm basis for discussion.
– Invisible Trihedron
Oct 3 at 21:24
add a comment
|
This is an informative answer. You could improve it further by adding quotations from Echoes of Honor to back up your statements. If this is the work that is being looked for, it will help TPO to recognize it as well as creating a firm basis for discussion.
– Invisible Trihedron
Oct 3 at 21:24
This is an informative answer. You could improve it further by adding quotations from Echoes of Honor to back up your statements. If this is the work that is being looked for, it will help TPO to recognize it as well as creating a firm basis for discussion.
– Invisible Trihedron
Oct 3 at 21:24
This is an informative answer. You could improve it further by adding quotations from Echoes of Honor to back up your statements. If this is the work that is being looked for, it will help TPO to recognize it as well as creating a firm basis for discussion.
– Invisible Trihedron
Oct 3 at 21:24
add a comment
|
Thanks for contributing an answer to Science Fiction & Fantasy Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function ()
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fscifi.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f220947%2f70s-80s-story-about-a-high-ranking-prisoner-of-war-on-a-prison-planet%23new-answer', 'question_page');
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function ()
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
);
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
This is an excellent description and a nice first post! Just a note that if you have anything else to add you can always edit your own posts.
– TheLethalCarrot
Oct 2 at 15:37
6
My first thought is the Vorkosigan story, "Borders of Infinity" (tor.com/2017/06/05/…), but that was a short story, there's no wood-based technology, and part of the issue is that there is no military structure due to how the Cetagandeans have structured things.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 15:52
1
Thanks, I can see the similarities but pretty sure that isn't it. The thing that sticks in my mind most is the reveal that the protagonist is the highest ranking person ever caught, in fact I think he might even have been 'famous' and there was some shock amongst the prisoners when they realise who he is. That doesn't seem to have been a feature of Borders of Infinity from the synopsis.
– TPO
Oct 2 at 16:01
@TPO: No. While Admiral Naismith (also Lord Vorkosigan in his birth persona) was indeed technically an extremely highly-ranked individual (although his rank was self-assigned, long story), he doesn't reveal his identity to the others until near the end of the story.
– FuzzyBoots
Oct 2 at 16:21
This is not the right answer, but a similar book (and an excellent read) is
A Planet Called Treason
by Orson Scott Card. It is also his first book, I believe.– BlackThorn
Oct 3 at 16:11