Is there any deeper thematic meaning to the white horse that Arya finds in The Bells (S08E05)?Does the intro sequence to the Game of Thrones TV series have any meaning?Is there any evidence that this character is a warg?What's the meaning behind the open-eyed stones that are placed on the deceased?Why didn't Daenerys' advisers suggest assassinating Cersei?Does Cersei deserve to be called a tyrant?How did Arya not get burned in S8E05, “The Bells”?

When was the famous "sudo warning" introduced? Under what background? By whom?

Could an American state survive nuclear war?

I wanna get a result of i/j . Like 1/3, 1/5, 1/7, 3/5, 3, 5/3... Something like that. But none of my code works

Double feature: Braaains

Why is my paper "under review" if it contains no results?

What actually is "unallocated space"?

Largest number order in string

Did I Traumatize My Puppy?

How to figure out key from key signature?

2000's spooky show with a group of teens telling spooky stories in the woods

Encountering former, abusive advisor at a conference

Why do military jets sometimes have elevators in a depressed position when parked?

Is it safe to pay bills over satellite internet?

How does Sitecore know an event in the event queue table has been processed?

Is it unusual that English uses possessive for past tense?

Are dead worlds a good galactic barrier?

In the twin paradox does the returning twin also come back permanently length contracted flatter than the twin on Earth?

Fat Cantor Set with large complement???

How are Aircraft Noses Designed?

Replace Shimano MT500 Caliper

Company indirectly discriminating against introverts, specifically INTJ

Need a function be continuous on a closed interval for the constitution of Intermediate Value Theorem?

Why is Mars cold?

Sum of all numbers in a string



Is there any deeper thematic meaning to the white horse that Arya finds in The Bells (S08E05)?


Does the intro sequence to the Game of Thrones TV series have any meaning?Is there any evidence that this character is a warg?What's the meaning behind the open-eyed stones that are placed on the deceased?Why didn't Daenerys' advisers suggest assassinating Cersei?Does Cersei deserve to be called a tyrant?How did Arya not get burned in S8E05, “The Bells”?






.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty
margin-bottom:0;









40

















In Game of Thrones S08E05 The Bells, after Daenerys starts




burning King's Landing to the ground, we follow the destruction through Arya's eyes, how she manages to evade death multiple times. She takes the responsibility of saving a few women and children through this ordeal but ultimately fails.


At the end, when she gets up and everything around her is ashes, a white horse appears out of nowhere and it's just standing there. Arya moves towards the horse as ashes fall from the sky like snow and rides the horse out of King's Landing.




Is there any deeper thematic meaning to the white horse? Or is it just a lucky coincidence? The scene looked beautiful, yet odd and contrasting from the rest of the episode.










share|improve this question























  • 10





    I don't think there's a deeper meaning to it unless it's Shadowfax from TLOTR. Truth be told, A Pale mare, with bloody sides is a symbol associated with the Bloody Flux. Maybe King's Landing is in for an epidemic I don't know.

    – Aegon
    May 14 at 16:54






  • 1





    @Aegon I don't know LOTR man

    – KharoBangdo
    May 14 at 17:00






  • 15





    @Aegon: maybe the next episode will reveal that the entire show was a dream Arya had after falling asleep during a particularly intense game of Oregon Trail.

    – Paul D. Waite
    May 14 at 17:33






  • 2





    Try not to look too much into it hehe much of the last season is fanservice, fanfiction, subverting expectations and red herrings

    – nodws
    May 14 at 23:43






  • 2





    @PaulD.Waite Yes - Arya will wake up back in her room at Winterfell as a young girl and sigh in relief that it was all a dream. Then a servant knocks at the door - her brother Bran has fallen from a tower window and is severely injured!

    – RobertF
    May 16 at 20:48

















40

















In Game of Thrones S08E05 The Bells, after Daenerys starts




burning King's Landing to the ground, we follow the destruction through Arya's eyes, how she manages to evade death multiple times. She takes the responsibility of saving a few women and children through this ordeal but ultimately fails.


At the end, when she gets up and everything around her is ashes, a white horse appears out of nowhere and it's just standing there. Arya moves towards the horse as ashes fall from the sky like snow and rides the horse out of King's Landing.




Is there any deeper thematic meaning to the white horse? Or is it just a lucky coincidence? The scene looked beautiful, yet odd and contrasting from the rest of the episode.










share|improve this question























  • 10





    I don't think there's a deeper meaning to it unless it's Shadowfax from TLOTR. Truth be told, A Pale mare, with bloody sides is a symbol associated with the Bloody Flux. Maybe King's Landing is in for an epidemic I don't know.

    – Aegon
    May 14 at 16:54






  • 1





    @Aegon I don't know LOTR man

    – KharoBangdo
    May 14 at 17:00






  • 15





    @Aegon: maybe the next episode will reveal that the entire show was a dream Arya had after falling asleep during a particularly intense game of Oregon Trail.

    – Paul D. Waite
    May 14 at 17:33






  • 2





    Try not to look too much into it hehe much of the last season is fanservice, fanfiction, subverting expectations and red herrings

    – nodws
    May 14 at 23:43






  • 2





    @PaulD.Waite Yes - Arya will wake up back in her room at Winterfell as a young girl and sigh in relief that it was all a dream. Then a servant knocks at the door - her brother Bran has fallen from a tower window and is severely injured!

    – RobertF
    May 16 at 20:48













40












40








40


1






In Game of Thrones S08E05 The Bells, after Daenerys starts




burning King's Landing to the ground, we follow the destruction through Arya's eyes, how she manages to evade death multiple times. She takes the responsibility of saving a few women and children through this ordeal but ultimately fails.


At the end, when she gets up and everything around her is ashes, a white horse appears out of nowhere and it's just standing there. Arya moves towards the horse as ashes fall from the sky like snow and rides the horse out of King's Landing.




Is there any deeper thematic meaning to the white horse? Or is it just a lucky coincidence? The scene looked beautiful, yet odd and contrasting from the rest of the episode.










share|improve this question

















In Game of Thrones S08E05 The Bells, after Daenerys starts




burning King's Landing to the ground, we follow the destruction through Arya's eyes, how she manages to evade death multiple times. She takes the responsibility of saving a few women and children through this ordeal but ultimately fails.


At the end, when she gets up and everything around her is ashes, a white horse appears out of nowhere and it's just standing there. Arya moves towards the horse as ashes fall from the sky like snow and rides the horse out of King's Landing.




Is there any deeper thematic meaning to the white horse? Or is it just a lucky coincidence? The scene looked beautiful, yet odd and contrasting from the rest of the episode.







game-of-thrones






share|improve this question
















share|improve this question













share|improve this question




share|improve this question








edited May 15 at 0:33









Möoz

34.3k27 gold badges226 silver badges387 bronze badges




34.3k27 gold badges226 silver badges387 bronze badges










asked May 14 at 16:39









KharoBangdoKharoBangdo

7,96213 gold badges47 silver badges87 bronze badges




7,96213 gold badges47 silver badges87 bronze badges










  • 10





    I don't think there's a deeper meaning to it unless it's Shadowfax from TLOTR. Truth be told, A Pale mare, with bloody sides is a symbol associated with the Bloody Flux. Maybe King's Landing is in for an epidemic I don't know.

    – Aegon
    May 14 at 16:54






  • 1





    @Aegon I don't know LOTR man

    – KharoBangdo
    May 14 at 17:00






  • 15





    @Aegon: maybe the next episode will reveal that the entire show was a dream Arya had after falling asleep during a particularly intense game of Oregon Trail.

    – Paul D. Waite
    May 14 at 17:33






  • 2





    Try not to look too much into it hehe much of the last season is fanservice, fanfiction, subverting expectations and red herrings

    – nodws
    May 14 at 23:43






  • 2





    @PaulD.Waite Yes - Arya will wake up back in her room at Winterfell as a young girl and sigh in relief that it was all a dream. Then a servant knocks at the door - her brother Bran has fallen from a tower window and is severely injured!

    – RobertF
    May 16 at 20:48












  • 10





    I don't think there's a deeper meaning to it unless it's Shadowfax from TLOTR. Truth be told, A Pale mare, with bloody sides is a symbol associated with the Bloody Flux. Maybe King's Landing is in for an epidemic I don't know.

    – Aegon
    May 14 at 16:54






  • 1





    @Aegon I don't know LOTR man

    – KharoBangdo
    May 14 at 17:00






  • 15





    @Aegon: maybe the next episode will reveal that the entire show was a dream Arya had after falling asleep during a particularly intense game of Oregon Trail.

    – Paul D. Waite
    May 14 at 17:33






  • 2





    Try not to look too much into it hehe much of the last season is fanservice, fanfiction, subverting expectations and red herrings

    – nodws
    May 14 at 23:43






  • 2





    @PaulD.Waite Yes - Arya will wake up back in her room at Winterfell as a young girl and sigh in relief that it was all a dream. Then a servant knocks at the door - her brother Bran has fallen from a tower window and is severely injured!

    – RobertF
    May 16 at 20:48







10




10





I don't think there's a deeper meaning to it unless it's Shadowfax from TLOTR. Truth be told, A Pale mare, with bloody sides is a symbol associated with the Bloody Flux. Maybe King's Landing is in for an epidemic I don't know.

– Aegon
May 14 at 16:54





I don't think there's a deeper meaning to it unless it's Shadowfax from TLOTR. Truth be told, A Pale mare, with bloody sides is a symbol associated with the Bloody Flux. Maybe King's Landing is in for an epidemic I don't know.

– Aegon
May 14 at 16:54




1




1





@Aegon I don't know LOTR man

– KharoBangdo
May 14 at 17:00





@Aegon I don't know LOTR man

– KharoBangdo
May 14 at 17:00




15




15





@Aegon: maybe the next episode will reveal that the entire show was a dream Arya had after falling asleep during a particularly intense game of Oregon Trail.

– Paul D. Waite
May 14 at 17:33





@Aegon: maybe the next episode will reveal that the entire show was a dream Arya had after falling asleep during a particularly intense game of Oregon Trail.

– Paul D. Waite
May 14 at 17:33




2




2





Try not to look too much into it hehe much of the last season is fanservice, fanfiction, subverting expectations and red herrings

– nodws
May 14 at 23:43





Try not to look too much into it hehe much of the last season is fanservice, fanfiction, subverting expectations and red herrings

– nodws
May 14 at 23:43




2




2





@PaulD.Waite Yes - Arya will wake up back in her room at Winterfell as a young girl and sigh in relief that it was all a dream. Then a servant knocks at the door - her brother Bran has fallen from a tower window and is severely injured!

– RobertF
May 16 at 20:48





@PaulD.Waite Yes - Arya will wake up back in her room at Winterfell as a young girl and sigh in relief that it was all a dream. Then a servant knocks at the door - her brother Bran has fallen from a tower window and is severely injured!

– RobertF
May 16 at 20:48










7 Answers
7






active

oldest

votes


















49


















It's (symbolically) the toy horse of the girl Arya tries to save



Credit for this observation to this Reddit user.



Toy horseBurnt toy horseReal horse



It's unclear to me what the meaning of this symbolism is. If I had to guess, I would say that perhaps the horse being a child's toy means that it represents innocence, and hence Arya's lost innocence which she is reclaiming. This would fit with the earlier scene in which Arya chooses not to accompany Sandor on his mission of revenge, and with the fact that Arya's list has been completed by Cersei's death.






share|improve this answer























  • 8





    As someone on that thread noted, Basically Dragonfire + Wooden horse = Real horse? :D

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:45






  • 5





    I strongly agree with this answer, although Aeg feels the need to be satirical about it I cannot see the reasoning for providing half a dozen shots of a toy horse which turns out to look exactly like (white horse red legs) the horse that comes for Arya without there being a relation. (Although I'm sure someone will, also satirically point out that the show's budget was slashed as the reason for these shots).

    – Edlothiad
    May 15 at 6:47






  • 5





    I don't know about innocence. The Arya's expression as she witnessed the death of innocents was revenge. She has added Dany to her list. I almost expected her to say "Daenerys" at the end there. She is in KL in preview.

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 6:51






  • 5





    Edlothiad I merely find the whole idea and fixation of show runners on the horse absurd, not the answer itself. Was the first upvote and all ;) Frankly I don't see any reason why it has to mean anything but as you say, the show runners apparently really really want it to mean something. Which is both sad and funny given how they simply didn't give any attention to important details like Idk the long night, Dany/Jon dynamics etc but they have time for the meaningless horseshots and king Daeron's nephew.

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 7:02






  • 13





    @zibadawatimmy nah, the horse will turn out to be Jaqen H'ghar in disguise!! : D

    – Grimm The Opiner
    May 15 at 8:36


















34


















That white horse is drawing comparisons to this verse from the Bible:




Revelation 6:8



And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death, and Hell followed with him. And power was given unto them over the fourth part of the earth, to kill with sword, and with hunger, and with death, and with the beasts of the earth.




Refers to the 4th horse of the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse. It is said that the rider of that horse is Death itself.






share|improve this answer























  • 67





    While this seems plausible, is it anything more than your own speculation? Without some confirmation from someone associated with the show, it's no more than a guess.

    – iayork
    May 14 at 18:28






  • 18





    Not to mention that Arya is a disciple of the death god (the one with many faces back in Bravos) and an assassin.

    – KorvinStarmast
    May 14 at 18:43






  • 7





    @knightscharge or it could be referring to her possible new mission... theringer.com/game-of-thrones/2019/5/13/18617922/…

    – kuhl
    May 14 at 19:58






  • 12





    One problem with this theory is that in Revelation it's the first horseman, Conquest, who is said to ride a white horse. Therefore it's important that Death's horse is "pale" and not white, and Arya's is definitely white. (In fact the word used in the original Greek is "chloros" which would usually be translated as "green" (like chlorophyll, chlorine) but in this case it's usually translated as "pale" or "ashen" since green isn't a colour that horses are. Another interpretation is that the horse is a sickly green colour. In any case it's not white.)

    – Oscar Cunningham
    May 15 at 0:13






  • 5





    @OscarCunningham It's an ash-covered Arabian Grey, I think. Pretty sure that "covered in ash" covers the "ashen" interpretation pretty well.

    – zibadawa timmy
    May 15 at 5:25


















17


















It may be a reference to the prophecy said by Quaithe in A Dance with Dragons (though not in the show):




The glass candles are burning. Soon comes the pale mare, and after her
the others. Kraken and dark flame, lion and griffin, the sun's son and
the mummer's dragon. Trust none of them. Remember the Undying. Beware
the perfumed seneschal.




More info






share|improve this answer





















  • 36





    Except it's obvious the writers haven't read the books, so i doubt they're referencing a prophecy from the book

    – Azor Ahai
    May 14 at 22:14






  • 13





    And the pale mare was the plague during the seige of meereen

    – Paul
    May 15 at 3:17






  • 5





    I strongly doubt this. This prophecy does not appear in the show, and the Glass Candles, Kraken (Victarion Greyjoy), Griffin (Jon Connington), Sun's Son (Quentyn Martell), and Mummer's Dragon (fAegon) are all written out of the show. Plus, as Paul says, the pale mare is clearly the plague in Meereen.

    – kuhl
    May 15 at 14:40











  • @AzorAhai: The omission of book story elements does not prove that they haven't read the books. Screentime is finite and not everything can make it into the show. There are also several cases of the show diverging from the books, and some of these changes are due to the difference between readers and viewers (e.g. Tyrion's severe disfigurement would have a dramatic impact on every Tyrion scene, whereas the books can ignore his disfigurement when it's an unnecessary distraction. A show cannot visually avoid it)

    – Flater
    May 16 at 9:50



















15


















Came across another interpretation on r/asoiaf by u/roadsiderose connecting it to Melisandre's vision in the books (unedited, emphasis mine)




When Melisandre asks R'hllor for a vision of Azor Ahai, she sees a vision of a girl as grey as ash fleeing on a dying horse.



I don't know if you noticed this in the last episode, but I was shocked to finally see Melisandre's vision in S8E5, when Arya flees King's Landing on that pale horse. Arya is the grey girl.




The girl. I must find the girl again, the grey girl on the dying
horse.
Jon Snow would expect that of her, and soon. It would not be
enough to say the girl was fleeing. He would want more, he would want
the when and where, and she did not have that for him. She had seen
the girl only once. A girl as grey as ash, and even as I watched she
crumbled and blew away. ~ Melisandre (ADWD)




This vision in the books, has been misinterpreted as Alys Karstark fleeing, was infact Arya at the end of Episode 5, when she mounts the pale mare covered in ash.







share|improve this answer























  • 4





    Did Melisandre make that prophecy in the show? I don't believe she did. In the books, she actually mistook Alys for Arya, not the other way around. It was misinterpreted, but only in the sense that she thought the girl was Arya. Books won't have the same ridiculous plot as the last few seasons, you may rest assured.

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:51











  • @Aegon i haven't read the books so I can't say. It's just a theory I came across that was relevant. That vision wasn't in the show afaik.

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 6:54






  • 2





    Well theories which are built on books material but are supposed to answer for show events are better left...on reddit I'd say. But that's of course my personal preference :)

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:59






  • 1





    @Aegon since other answers also relied on book only theories, I thought one more wouldn't harm anyone :-)

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 7:19











  • It's a parallel, to be sure.

    – Möoz
    May 15 at 9:24


















7


















Fact: It is symbolic of her hope and new mission

The horse appearing, against all odds, at the most opportune time and ready to carry her, is a symbol of a new beginning.



Whether it's the beginning of a new mission to assassinate Daenerys for what she did, or a mission to escape and find solace is yet to be determined.



Possibility: It is a symbol of the 'Pale Mare' prophecy

Daenerys had a prophecy (in the books) where a 'Pale Mare' would come forth, carrying death towards her. This hasn't been payed out in the show (and I'm not sure it was alluded to), but it certainly is a potential symbol.



In the books, the 'Pale Mare' carried a deadly flu (as mentioned in StarHawk's answer); in this case, it would be carrying Arya, the personification of death.



Improbability: It is Dany's own horse, her beloved 'Silver'

In my mind, it is Daenerys' own horse 'The Silver'. It's so pissed off about what Dany did, that it decided to leave and go over to Arya.






share|improve this answer


























  • Didn't Silver die a few seasons ago?

    – berry120
    May 16 at 0:16











  • @berry120 You're right it did.

    – Möoz
    May 16 at 0:19






  • 3





    Plot-twistability: the horse is dead, just like Arya is also dead. She just happens to be able to wander among the living because the NK touched her in 8x3.

    – walen
    May 16 at 8:05







  • 1





    @walen I like it, but it's too deep for this show :-p

    – Möoz
    May 16 at 22:08


















1


















I have come across two explanations for the horse appearing for Arya:



  1. Shadowfax is taking her to heal at the house of Elrond


  2. Bran rescuing her via warg






share|improve this answer





















  • 10





    This would be better if you kept the LOTR joke answer out of it and instead focused on the Bran warging to rescue her.

    – TheLethalCarrot
    May 15 at 13:36






  • 4





    @TheLethalCarrot Problem is either option seems equally likely at this point.

    – The Head Rush
    May 15 at 17:10






  • 1





    @TheLethalCarrot D&D will clumsily christen that horse "Shadowwolf"... mark my words!

    – Mateen Ulhaq
    May 16 at 23:24


















0


















Probably not, or there's at least no evidence suggesting it.



Thematically, a white horse means plague. The Pale Mare is the epithet of a disease known as the Bloody Flux, which appears in the books but not in the show.



If we abandon fantastic conspiracy theories with no evidence, then there's this:



Horses tend to panic when they smell smoke or get exposed to flames. Or dragons, presumably. So one can perhaps assume that this is a combat trained horse.



There is a commander of the Golden Company riding a white horse earlier in the same episode. He is in fact the only defender on horse, so it is probably his horse.



Or it could have belonged to a fallen dothraki.






share|improve this answer


























  • Looking at the pattern on it's muzzle I think the two horses are being played by the same actor. They also have the same bridle. But I don't think they're supposed to be the same horse because there is also a shot of Strickland's horse lying dead in the mud.

    – Oscar Cunningham
    May 15 at 18:20






  • 1





    @OscarCunningham Arya's found horse looks a bit bruised up though. Are you sure the first white horse actually died and didn't just get knocked out? :)

    – Amarth
    May 16 at 15:44










protected by Aegon May 16 at 14:53



Thank you for your interest in this question.
Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).



Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?














7 Answers
7






active

oldest

votes








7 Answers
7






active

oldest

votes









active

oldest

votes






active

oldest

votes









49


















It's (symbolically) the toy horse of the girl Arya tries to save



Credit for this observation to this Reddit user.



Toy horseBurnt toy horseReal horse



It's unclear to me what the meaning of this symbolism is. If I had to guess, I would say that perhaps the horse being a child's toy means that it represents innocence, and hence Arya's lost innocence which she is reclaiming. This would fit with the earlier scene in which Arya chooses not to accompany Sandor on his mission of revenge, and with the fact that Arya's list has been completed by Cersei's death.






share|improve this answer























  • 8





    As someone on that thread noted, Basically Dragonfire + Wooden horse = Real horse? :D

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:45






  • 5





    I strongly agree with this answer, although Aeg feels the need to be satirical about it I cannot see the reasoning for providing half a dozen shots of a toy horse which turns out to look exactly like (white horse red legs) the horse that comes for Arya without there being a relation. (Although I'm sure someone will, also satirically point out that the show's budget was slashed as the reason for these shots).

    – Edlothiad
    May 15 at 6:47






  • 5





    I don't know about innocence. The Arya's expression as she witnessed the death of innocents was revenge. She has added Dany to her list. I almost expected her to say "Daenerys" at the end there. She is in KL in preview.

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 6:51






  • 5





    Edlothiad I merely find the whole idea and fixation of show runners on the horse absurd, not the answer itself. Was the first upvote and all ;) Frankly I don't see any reason why it has to mean anything but as you say, the show runners apparently really really want it to mean something. Which is both sad and funny given how they simply didn't give any attention to important details like Idk the long night, Dany/Jon dynamics etc but they have time for the meaningless horseshots and king Daeron's nephew.

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 7:02






  • 13





    @zibadawatimmy nah, the horse will turn out to be Jaqen H'ghar in disguise!! : D

    – Grimm The Opiner
    May 15 at 8:36















49


















It's (symbolically) the toy horse of the girl Arya tries to save



Credit for this observation to this Reddit user.



Toy horseBurnt toy horseReal horse



It's unclear to me what the meaning of this symbolism is. If I had to guess, I would say that perhaps the horse being a child's toy means that it represents innocence, and hence Arya's lost innocence which she is reclaiming. This would fit with the earlier scene in which Arya chooses not to accompany Sandor on his mission of revenge, and with the fact that Arya's list has been completed by Cersei's death.






share|improve this answer























  • 8





    As someone on that thread noted, Basically Dragonfire + Wooden horse = Real horse? :D

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:45






  • 5





    I strongly agree with this answer, although Aeg feels the need to be satirical about it I cannot see the reasoning for providing half a dozen shots of a toy horse which turns out to look exactly like (white horse red legs) the horse that comes for Arya without there being a relation. (Although I'm sure someone will, also satirically point out that the show's budget was slashed as the reason for these shots).

    – Edlothiad
    May 15 at 6:47






  • 5





    I don't know about innocence. The Arya's expression as she witnessed the death of innocents was revenge. She has added Dany to her list. I almost expected her to say "Daenerys" at the end there. She is in KL in preview.

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 6:51






  • 5





    Edlothiad I merely find the whole idea and fixation of show runners on the horse absurd, not the answer itself. Was the first upvote and all ;) Frankly I don't see any reason why it has to mean anything but as you say, the show runners apparently really really want it to mean something. Which is both sad and funny given how they simply didn't give any attention to important details like Idk the long night, Dany/Jon dynamics etc but they have time for the meaningless horseshots and king Daeron's nephew.

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 7:02






  • 13





    @zibadawatimmy nah, the horse will turn out to be Jaqen H'ghar in disguise!! : D

    – Grimm The Opiner
    May 15 at 8:36













49














49










49









It's (symbolically) the toy horse of the girl Arya tries to save



Credit for this observation to this Reddit user.



Toy horseBurnt toy horseReal horse



It's unclear to me what the meaning of this symbolism is. If I had to guess, I would say that perhaps the horse being a child's toy means that it represents innocence, and hence Arya's lost innocence which she is reclaiming. This would fit with the earlier scene in which Arya chooses not to accompany Sandor on his mission of revenge, and with the fact that Arya's list has been completed by Cersei's death.






share|improve this answer
















It's (symbolically) the toy horse of the girl Arya tries to save



Credit for this observation to this Reddit user.



Toy horseBurnt toy horseReal horse



It's unclear to me what the meaning of this symbolism is. If I had to guess, I would say that perhaps the horse being a child's toy means that it represents innocence, and hence Arya's lost innocence which she is reclaiming. This would fit with the earlier scene in which Arya chooses not to accompany Sandor on his mission of revenge, and with the fact that Arya's list has been completed by Cersei's death.







share|improve this answer















share|improve this answer




share|improve this answer








edited May 15 at 22:36

























answered May 15 at 6:41









Oscar CunninghamOscar Cunningham

1,2021 gold badge5 silver badges7 bronze badges




1,2021 gold badge5 silver badges7 bronze badges










  • 8





    As someone on that thread noted, Basically Dragonfire + Wooden horse = Real horse? :D

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:45






  • 5





    I strongly agree with this answer, although Aeg feels the need to be satirical about it I cannot see the reasoning for providing half a dozen shots of a toy horse which turns out to look exactly like (white horse red legs) the horse that comes for Arya without there being a relation. (Although I'm sure someone will, also satirically point out that the show's budget was slashed as the reason for these shots).

    – Edlothiad
    May 15 at 6:47






  • 5





    I don't know about innocence. The Arya's expression as she witnessed the death of innocents was revenge. She has added Dany to her list. I almost expected her to say "Daenerys" at the end there. She is in KL in preview.

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 6:51






  • 5





    Edlothiad I merely find the whole idea and fixation of show runners on the horse absurd, not the answer itself. Was the first upvote and all ;) Frankly I don't see any reason why it has to mean anything but as you say, the show runners apparently really really want it to mean something. Which is both sad and funny given how they simply didn't give any attention to important details like Idk the long night, Dany/Jon dynamics etc but they have time for the meaningless horseshots and king Daeron's nephew.

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 7:02






  • 13





    @zibadawatimmy nah, the horse will turn out to be Jaqen H'ghar in disguise!! : D

    – Grimm The Opiner
    May 15 at 8:36












  • 8





    As someone on that thread noted, Basically Dragonfire + Wooden horse = Real horse? :D

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:45






  • 5





    I strongly agree with this answer, although Aeg feels the need to be satirical about it I cannot see the reasoning for providing half a dozen shots of a toy horse which turns out to look exactly like (white horse red legs) the horse that comes for Arya without there being a relation. (Although I'm sure someone will, also satirically point out that the show's budget was slashed as the reason for these shots).

    – Edlothiad
    May 15 at 6:47






  • 5





    I don't know about innocence. The Arya's expression as she witnessed the death of innocents was revenge. She has added Dany to her list. I almost expected her to say "Daenerys" at the end there. She is in KL in preview.

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 6:51






  • 5





    Edlothiad I merely find the whole idea and fixation of show runners on the horse absurd, not the answer itself. Was the first upvote and all ;) Frankly I don't see any reason why it has to mean anything but as you say, the show runners apparently really really want it to mean something. Which is both sad and funny given how they simply didn't give any attention to important details like Idk the long night, Dany/Jon dynamics etc but they have time for the meaningless horseshots and king Daeron's nephew.

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 7:02






  • 13





    @zibadawatimmy nah, the horse will turn out to be Jaqen H'ghar in disguise!! : D

    – Grimm The Opiner
    May 15 at 8:36







8




8





As someone on that thread noted, Basically Dragonfire + Wooden horse = Real horse? :D

– Aegon
May 15 at 6:45





As someone on that thread noted, Basically Dragonfire + Wooden horse = Real horse? :D

– Aegon
May 15 at 6:45




5




5





I strongly agree with this answer, although Aeg feels the need to be satirical about it I cannot see the reasoning for providing half a dozen shots of a toy horse which turns out to look exactly like (white horse red legs) the horse that comes for Arya without there being a relation. (Although I'm sure someone will, also satirically point out that the show's budget was slashed as the reason for these shots).

– Edlothiad
May 15 at 6:47





I strongly agree with this answer, although Aeg feels the need to be satirical about it I cannot see the reasoning for providing half a dozen shots of a toy horse which turns out to look exactly like (white horse red legs) the horse that comes for Arya without there being a relation. (Although I'm sure someone will, also satirically point out that the show's budget was slashed as the reason for these shots).

– Edlothiad
May 15 at 6:47




5




5





I don't know about innocence. The Arya's expression as she witnessed the death of innocents was revenge. She has added Dany to her list. I almost expected her to say "Daenerys" at the end there. She is in KL in preview.

– KharoBangdo
May 15 at 6:51





I don't know about innocence. The Arya's expression as she witnessed the death of innocents was revenge. She has added Dany to her list. I almost expected her to say "Daenerys" at the end there. She is in KL in preview.

– KharoBangdo
May 15 at 6:51




5




5





Edlothiad I merely find the whole idea and fixation of show runners on the horse absurd, not the answer itself. Was the first upvote and all ;) Frankly I don't see any reason why it has to mean anything but as you say, the show runners apparently really really want it to mean something. Which is both sad and funny given how they simply didn't give any attention to important details like Idk the long night, Dany/Jon dynamics etc but they have time for the meaningless horseshots and king Daeron's nephew.

– Aegon
May 15 at 7:02





Edlothiad I merely find the whole idea and fixation of show runners on the horse absurd, not the answer itself. Was the first upvote and all ;) Frankly I don't see any reason why it has to mean anything but as you say, the show runners apparently really really want it to mean something. Which is both sad and funny given how they simply didn't give any attention to important details like Idk the long night, Dany/Jon dynamics etc but they have time for the meaningless horseshots and king Daeron's nephew.

– Aegon
May 15 at 7:02




13




13





@zibadawatimmy nah, the horse will turn out to be Jaqen H'ghar in disguise!! : D

– Grimm The Opiner
May 15 at 8:36





@zibadawatimmy nah, the horse will turn out to be Jaqen H'ghar in disguise!! : D

– Grimm The Opiner
May 15 at 8:36













34


















That white horse is drawing comparisons to this verse from the Bible:




Revelation 6:8



And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death, and Hell followed with him. And power was given unto them over the fourth part of the earth, to kill with sword, and with hunger, and with death, and with the beasts of the earth.




Refers to the 4th horse of the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse. It is said that the rider of that horse is Death itself.






share|improve this answer























  • 67





    While this seems plausible, is it anything more than your own speculation? Without some confirmation from someone associated with the show, it's no more than a guess.

    – iayork
    May 14 at 18:28






  • 18





    Not to mention that Arya is a disciple of the death god (the one with many faces back in Bravos) and an assassin.

    – KorvinStarmast
    May 14 at 18:43






  • 7





    @knightscharge or it could be referring to her possible new mission... theringer.com/game-of-thrones/2019/5/13/18617922/…

    – kuhl
    May 14 at 19:58






  • 12





    One problem with this theory is that in Revelation it's the first horseman, Conquest, who is said to ride a white horse. Therefore it's important that Death's horse is "pale" and not white, and Arya's is definitely white. (In fact the word used in the original Greek is "chloros" which would usually be translated as "green" (like chlorophyll, chlorine) but in this case it's usually translated as "pale" or "ashen" since green isn't a colour that horses are. Another interpretation is that the horse is a sickly green colour. In any case it's not white.)

    – Oscar Cunningham
    May 15 at 0:13






  • 5





    @OscarCunningham It's an ash-covered Arabian Grey, I think. Pretty sure that "covered in ash" covers the "ashen" interpretation pretty well.

    – zibadawa timmy
    May 15 at 5:25















34


















That white horse is drawing comparisons to this verse from the Bible:




Revelation 6:8



And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death, and Hell followed with him. And power was given unto them over the fourth part of the earth, to kill with sword, and with hunger, and with death, and with the beasts of the earth.




Refers to the 4th horse of the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse. It is said that the rider of that horse is Death itself.






share|improve this answer























  • 67





    While this seems plausible, is it anything more than your own speculation? Without some confirmation from someone associated with the show, it's no more than a guess.

    – iayork
    May 14 at 18:28






  • 18





    Not to mention that Arya is a disciple of the death god (the one with many faces back in Bravos) and an assassin.

    – KorvinStarmast
    May 14 at 18:43






  • 7





    @knightscharge or it could be referring to her possible new mission... theringer.com/game-of-thrones/2019/5/13/18617922/…

    – kuhl
    May 14 at 19:58






  • 12





    One problem with this theory is that in Revelation it's the first horseman, Conquest, who is said to ride a white horse. Therefore it's important that Death's horse is "pale" and not white, and Arya's is definitely white. (In fact the word used in the original Greek is "chloros" which would usually be translated as "green" (like chlorophyll, chlorine) but in this case it's usually translated as "pale" or "ashen" since green isn't a colour that horses are. Another interpretation is that the horse is a sickly green colour. In any case it's not white.)

    – Oscar Cunningham
    May 15 at 0:13






  • 5





    @OscarCunningham It's an ash-covered Arabian Grey, I think. Pretty sure that "covered in ash" covers the "ashen" interpretation pretty well.

    – zibadawa timmy
    May 15 at 5:25













34














34










34









That white horse is drawing comparisons to this verse from the Bible:




Revelation 6:8



And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death, and Hell followed with him. And power was given unto them over the fourth part of the earth, to kill with sword, and with hunger, and with death, and with the beasts of the earth.




Refers to the 4th horse of the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse. It is said that the rider of that horse is Death itself.






share|improve this answer
















That white horse is drawing comparisons to this verse from the Bible:




Revelation 6:8



And I looked, and behold a pale horse: and his name that sat on him was Death, and Hell followed with him. And power was given unto them over the fourth part of the earth, to kill with sword, and with hunger, and with death, and with the beasts of the earth.




Refers to the 4th horse of the 4 horsemen of the apocalypse. It is said that the rider of that horse is Death itself.







share|improve this answer















share|improve this answer




share|improve this answer








edited May 14 at 17:28

























answered May 14 at 17:22









Anshuman DikhitAnshuman Dikhit

2,0351 gold badge5 silver badges13 bronze badges




2,0351 gold badge5 silver badges13 bronze badges










  • 67





    While this seems plausible, is it anything more than your own speculation? Without some confirmation from someone associated with the show, it's no more than a guess.

    – iayork
    May 14 at 18:28






  • 18





    Not to mention that Arya is a disciple of the death god (the one with many faces back in Bravos) and an assassin.

    – KorvinStarmast
    May 14 at 18:43






  • 7





    @knightscharge or it could be referring to her possible new mission... theringer.com/game-of-thrones/2019/5/13/18617922/…

    – kuhl
    May 14 at 19:58






  • 12





    One problem with this theory is that in Revelation it's the first horseman, Conquest, who is said to ride a white horse. Therefore it's important that Death's horse is "pale" and not white, and Arya's is definitely white. (In fact the word used in the original Greek is "chloros" which would usually be translated as "green" (like chlorophyll, chlorine) but in this case it's usually translated as "pale" or "ashen" since green isn't a colour that horses are. Another interpretation is that the horse is a sickly green colour. In any case it's not white.)

    – Oscar Cunningham
    May 15 at 0:13






  • 5





    @OscarCunningham It's an ash-covered Arabian Grey, I think. Pretty sure that "covered in ash" covers the "ashen" interpretation pretty well.

    – zibadawa timmy
    May 15 at 5:25












  • 67





    While this seems plausible, is it anything more than your own speculation? Without some confirmation from someone associated with the show, it's no more than a guess.

    – iayork
    May 14 at 18:28






  • 18





    Not to mention that Arya is a disciple of the death god (the one with many faces back in Bravos) and an assassin.

    – KorvinStarmast
    May 14 at 18:43






  • 7





    @knightscharge or it could be referring to her possible new mission... theringer.com/game-of-thrones/2019/5/13/18617922/…

    – kuhl
    May 14 at 19:58






  • 12





    One problem with this theory is that in Revelation it's the first horseman, Conquest, who is said to ride a white horse. Therefore it's important that Death's horse is "pale" and not white, and Arya's is definitely white. (In fact the word used in the original Greek is "chloros" which would usually be translated as "green" (like chlorophyll, chlorine) but in this case it's usually translated as "pale" or "ashen" since green isn't a colour that horses are. Another interpretation is that the horse is a sickly green colour. In any case it's not white.)

    – Oscar Cunningham
    May 15 at 0:13






  • 5





    @OscarCunningham It's an ash-covered Arabian Grey, I think. Pretty sure that "covered in ash" covers the "ashen" interpretation pretty well.

    – zibadawa timmy
    May 15 at 5:25







67




67





While this seems plausible, is it anything more than your own speculation? Without some confirmation from someone associated with the show, it's no more than a guess.

– iayork
May 14 at 18:28





While this seems plausible, is it anything more than your own speculation? Without some confirmation from someone associated with the show, it's no more than a guess.

– iayork
May 14 at 18:28




18




18





Not to mention that Arya is a disciple of the death god (the one with many faces back in Bravos) and an assassin.

– KorvinStarmast
May 14 at 18:43





Not to mention that Arya is a disciple of the death god (the one with many faces back in Bravos) and an assassin.

– KorvinStarmast
May 14 at 18:43




7




7





@knightscharge or it could be referring to her possible new mission... theringer.com/game-of-thrones/2019/5/13/18617922/…

– kuhl
May 14 at 19:58





@knightscharge or it could be referring to her possible new mission... theringer.com/game-of-thrones/2019/5/13/18617922/…

– kuhl
May 14 at 19:58




12




12





One problem with this theory is that in Revelation it's the first horseman, Conquest, who is said to ride a white horse. Therefore it's important that Death's horse is "pale" and not white, and Arya's is definitely white. (In fact the word used in the original Greek is "chloros" which would usually be translated as "green" (like chlorophyll, chlorine) but in this case it's usually translated as "pale" or "ashen" since green isn't a colour that horses are. Another interpretation is that the horse is a sickly green colour. In any case it's not white.)

– Oscar Cunningham
May 15 at 0:13





One problem with this theory is that in Revelation it's the first horseman, Conquest, who is said to ride a white horse. Therefore it's important that Death's horse is "pale" and not white, and Arya's is definitely white. (In fact the word used in the original Greek is "chloros" which would usually be translated as "green" (like chlorophyll, chlorine) but in this case it's usually translated as "pale" or "ashen" since green isn't a colour that horses are. Another interpretation is that the horse is a sickly green colour. In any case it's not white.)

– Oscar Cunningham
May 15 at 0:13




5




5





@OscarCunningham It's an ash-covered Arabian Grey, I think. Pretty sure that "covered in ash" covers the "ashen" interpretation pretty well.

– zibadawa timmy
May 15 at 5:25





@OscarCunningham It's an ash-covered Arabian Grey, I think. Pretty sure that "covered in ash" covers the "ashen" interpretation pretty well.

– zibadawa timmy
May 15 at 5:25











17


















It may be a reference to the prophecy said by Quaithe in A Dance with Dragons (though not in the show):




The glass candles are burning. Soon comes the pale mare, and after her
the others. Kraken and dark flame, lion and griffin, the sun's son and
the mummer's dragon. Trust none of them. Remember the Undying. Beware
the perfumed seneschal.




More info






share|improve this answer





















  • 36





    Except it's obvious the writers haven't read the books, so i doubt they're referencing a prophecy from the book

    – Azor Ahai
    May 14 at 22:14






  • 13





    And the pale mare was the plague during the seige of meereen

    – Paul
    May 15 at 3:17






  • 5





    I strongly doubt this. This prophecy does not appear in the show, and the Glass Candles, Kraken (Victarion Greyjoy), Griffin (Jon Connington), Sun's Son (Quentyn Martell), and Mummer's Dragon (fAegon) are all written out of the show. Plus, as Paul says, the pale mare is clearly the plague in Meereen.

    – kuhl
    May 15 at 14:40











  • @AzorAhai: The omission of book story elements does not prove that they haven't read the books. Screentime is finite and not everything can make it into the show. There are also several cases of the show diverging from the books, and some of these changes are due to the difference between readers and viewers (e.g. Tyrion's severe disfigurement would have a dramatic impact on every Tyrion scene, whereas the books can ignore his disfigurement when it's an unnecessary distraction. A show cannot visually avoid it)

    – Flater
    May 16 at 9:50
















17


















It may be a reference to the prophecy said by Quaithe in A Dance with Dragons (though not in the show):




The glass candles are burning. Soon comes the pale mare, and after her
the others. Kraken and dark flame, lion and griffin, the sun's son and
the mummer's dragon. Trust none of them. Remember the Undying. Beware
the perfumed seneschal.




More info






share|improve this answer





















  • 36





    Except it's obvious the writers haven't read the books, so i doubt they're referencing a prophecy from the book

    – Azor Ahai
    May 14 at 22:14






  • 13





    And the pale mare was the plague during the seige of meereen

    – Paul
    May 15 at 3:17






  • 5





    I strongly doubt this. This prophecy does not appear in the show, and the Glass Candles, Kraken (Victarion Greyjoy), Griffin (Jon Connington), Sun's Son (Quentyn Martell), and Mummer's Dragon (fAegon) are all written out of the show. Plus, as Paul says, the pale mare is clearly the plague in Meereen.

    – kuhl
    May 15 at 14:40











  • @AzorAhai: The omission of book story elements does not prove that they haven't read the books. Screentime is finite and not everything can make it into the show. There are also several cases of the show diverging from the books, and some of these changes are due to the difference between readers and viewers (e.g. Tyrion's severe disfigurement would have a dramatic impact on every Tyrion scene, whereas the books can ignore his disfigurement when it's an unnecessary distraction. A show cannot visually avoid it)

    – Flater
    May 16 at 9:50














17














17










17









It may be a reference to the prophecy said by Quaithe in A Dance with Dragons (though not in the show):




The glass candles are burning. Soon comes the pale mare, and after her
the others. Kraken and dark flame, lion and griffin, the sun's son and
the mummer's dragon. Trust none of them. Remember the Undying. Beware
the perfumed seneschal.




More info






share|improve this answer














It may be a reference to the prophecy said by Quaithe in A Dance with Dragons (though not in the show):




The glass candles are burning. Soon comes the pale mare, and after her
the others. Kraken and dark flame, lion and griffin, the sun's son and
the mummer's dragon. Trust none of them. Remember the Undying. Beware
the perfumed seneschal.




More info







share|improve this answer













share|improve this answer




share|improve this answer










answered May 14 at 19:23









StarHawkStarHawk

1,2954 silver badges14 bronze badges




1,2954 silver badges14 bronze badges










  • 36





    Except it's obvious the writers haven't read the books, so i doubt they're referencing a prophecy from the book

    – Azor Ahai
    May 14 at 22:14






  • 13





    And the pale mare was the plague during the seige of meereen

    – Paul
    May 15 at 3:17






  • 5





    I strongly doubt this. This prophecy does not appear in the show, and the Glass Candles, Kraken (Victarion Greyjoy), Griffin (Jon Connington), Sun's Son (Quentyn Martell), and Mummer's Dragon (fAegon) are all written out of the show. Plus, as Paul says, the pale mare is clearly the plague in Meereen.

    – kuhl
    May 15 at 14:40











  • @AzorAhai: The omission of book story elements does not prove that they haven't read the books. Screentime is finite and not everything can make it into the show. There are also several cases of the show diverging from the books, and some of these changes are due to the difference between readers and viewers (e.g. Tyrion's severe disfigurement would have a dramatic impact on every Tyrion scene, whereas the books can ignore his disfigurement when it's an unnecessary distraction. A show cannot visually avoid it)

    – Flater
    May 16 at 9:50













  • 36





    Except it's obvious the writers haven't read the books, so i doubt they're referencing a prophecy from the book

    – Azor Ahai
    May 14 at 22:14






  • 13





    And the pale mare was the plague during the seige of meereen

    – Paul
    May 15 at 3:17






  • 5





    I strongly doubt this. This prophecy does not appear in the show, and the Glass Candles, Kraken (Victarion Greyjoy), Griffin (Jon Connington), Sun's Son (Quentyn Martell), and Mummer's Dragon (fAegon) are all written out of the show. Plus, as Paul says, the pale mare is clearly the plague in Meereen.

    – kuhl
    May 15 at 14:40











  • @AzorAhai: The omission of book story elements does not prove that they haven't read the books. Screentime is finite and not everything can make it into the show. There are also several cases of the show diverging from the books, and some of these changes are due to the difference between readers and viewers (e.g. Tyrion's severe disfigurement would have a dramatic impact on every Tyrion scene, whereas the books can ignore his disfigurement when it's an unnecessary distraction. A show cannot visually avoid it)

    – Flater
    May 16 at 9:50








36




36





Except it's obvious the writers haven't read the books, so i doubt they're referencing a prophecy from the book

– Azor Ahai
May 14 at 22:14





Except it's obvious the writers haven't read the books, so i doubt they're referencing a prophecy from the book

– Azor Ahai
May 14 at 22:14




13




13





And the pale mare was the plague during the seige of meereen

– Paul
May 15 at 3:17





And the pale mare was the plague during the seige of meereen

– Paul
May 15 at 3:17




5




5





I strongly doubt this. This prophecy does not appear in the show, and the Glass Candles, Kraken (Victarion Greyjoy), Griffin (Jon Connington), Sun's Son (Quentyn Martell), and Mummer's Dragon (fAegon) are all written out of the show. Plus, as Paul says, the pale mare is clearly the plague in Meereen.

– kuhl
May 15 at 14:40





I strongly doubt this. This prophecy does not appear in the show, and the Glass Candles, Kraken (Victarion Greyjoy), Griffin (Jon Connington), Sun's Son (Quentyn Martell), and Mummer's Dragon (fAegon) are all written out of the show. Plus, as Paul says, the pale mare is clearly the plague in Meereen.

– kuhl
May 15 at 14:40













@AzorAhai: The omission of book story elements does not prove that they haven't read the books. Screentime is finite and not everything can make it into the show. There are also several cases of the show diverging from the books, and some of these changes are due to the difference between readers and viewers (e.g. Tyrion's severe disfigurement would have a dramatic impact on every Tyrion scene, whereas the books can ignore his disfigurement when it's an unnecessary distraction. A show cannot visually avoid it)

– Flater
May 16 at 9:50






@AzorAhai: The omission of book story elements does not prove that they haven't read the books. Screentime is finite and not everything can make it into the show. There are also several cases of the show diverging from the books, and some of these changes are due to the difference between readers and viewers (e.g. Tyrion's severe disfigurement would have a dramatic impact on every Tyrion scene, whereas the books can ignore his disfigurement when it's an unnecessary distraction. A show cannot visually avoid it)

– Flater
May 16 at 9:50












15


















Came across another interpretation on r/asoiaf by u/roadsiderose connecting it to Melisandre's vision in the books (unedited, emphasis mine)




When Melisandre asks R'hllor for a vision of Azor Ahai, she sees a vision of a girl as grey as ash fleeing on a dying horse.



I don't know if you noticed this in the last episode, but I was shocked to finally see Melisandre's vision in S8E5, when Arya flees King's Landing on that pale horse. Arya is the grey girl.




The girl. I must find the girl again, the grey girl on the dying
horse.
Jon Snow would expect that of her, and soon. It would not be
enough to say the girl was fleeing. He would want more, he would want
the when and where, and she did not have that for him. She had seen
the girl only once. A girl as grey as ash, and even as I watched she
crumbled and blew away. ~ Melisandre (ADWD)




This vision in the books, has been misinterpreted as Alys Karstark fleeing, was infact Arya at the end of Episode 5, when she mounts the pale mare covered in ash.







share|improve this answer























  • 4





    Did Melisandre make that prophecy in the show? I don't believe she did. In the books, she actually mistook Alys for Arya, not the other way around. It was misinterpreted, but only in the sense that she thought the girl was Arya. Books won't have the same ridiculous plot as the last few seasons, you may rest assured.

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:51











  • @Aegon i haven't read the books so I can't say. It's just a theory I came across that was relevant. That vision wasn't in the show afaik.

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 6:54






  • 2





    Well theories which are built on books material but are supposed to answer for show events are better left...on reddit I'd say. But that's of course my personal preference :)

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:59






  • 1





    @Aegon since other answers also relied on book only theories, I thought one more wouldn't harm anyone :-)

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 7:19











  • It's a parallel, to be sure.

    – Möoz
    May 15 at 9:24















15


















Came across another interpretation on r/asoiaf by u/roadsiderose connecting it to Melisandre's vision in the books (unedited, emphasis mine)




When Melisandre asks R'hllor for a vision of Azor Ahai, she sees a vision of a girl as grey as ash fleeing on a dying horse.



I don't know if you noticed this in the last episode, but I was shocked to finally see Melisandre's vision in S8E5, when Arya flees King's Landing on that pale horse. Arya is the grey girl.




The girl. I must find the girl again, the grey girl on the dying
horse.
Jon Snow would expect that of her, and soon. It would not be
enough to say the girl was fleeing. He would want more, he would want
the when and where, and she did not have that for him. She had seen
the girl only once. A girl as grey as ash, and even as I watched she
crumbled and blew away. ~ Melisandre (ADWD)




This vision in the books, has been misinterpreted as Alys Karstark fleeing, was infact Arya at the end of Episode 5, when she mounts the pale mare covered in ash.







share|improve this answer























  • 4





    Did Melisandre make that prophecy in the show? I don't believe she did. In the books, she actually mistook Alys for Arya, not the other way around. It was misinterpreted, but only in the sense that she thought the girl was Arya. Books won't have the same ridiculous plot as the last few seasons, you may rest assured.

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:51











  • @Aegon i haven't read the books so I can't say. It's just a theory I came across that was relevant. That vision wasn't in the show afaik.

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 6:54






  • 2





    Well theories which are built on books material but are supposed to answer for show events are better left...on reddit I'd say. But that's of course my personal preference :)

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:59






  • 1





    @Aegon since other answers also relied on book only theories, I thought one more wouldn't harm anyone :-)

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 7:19











  • It's a parallel, to be sure.

    – Möoz
    May 15 at 9:24













15














15










15









Came across another interpretation on r/asoiaf by u/roadsiderose connecting it to Melisandre's vision in the books (unedited, emphasis mine)




When Melisandre asks R'hllor for a vision of Azor Ahai, she sees a vision of a girl as grey as ash fleeing on a dying horse.



I don't know if you noticed this in the last episode, but I was shocked to finally see Melisandre's vision in S8E5, when Arya flees King's Landing on that pale horse. Arya is the grey girl.




The girl. I must find the girl again, the grey girl on the dying
horse.
Jon Snow would expect that of her, and soon. It would not be
enough to say the girl was fleeing. He would want more, he would want
the when and where, and she did not have that for him. She had seen
the girl only once. A girl as grey as ash, and even as I watched she
crumbled and blew away. ~ Melisandre (ADWD)




This vision in the books, has been misinterpreted as Alys Karstark fleeing, was infact Arya at the end of Episode 5, when she mounts the pale mare covered in ash.







share|improve this answer
















Came across another interpretation on r/asoiaf by u/roadsiderose connecting it to Melisandre's vision in the books (unedited, emphasis mine)




When Melisandre asks R'hllor for a vision of Azor Ahai, she sees a vision of a girl as grey as ash fleeing on a dying horse.



I don't know if you noticed this in the last episode, but I was shocked to finally see Melisandre's vision in S8E5, when Arya flees King's Landing on that pale horse. Arya is the grey girl.




The girl. I must find the girl again, the grey girl on the dying
horse.
Jon Snow would expect that of her, and soon. It would not be
enough to say the girl was fleeing. He would want more, he would want
the when and where, and she did not have that for him. She had seen
the girl only once. A girl as grey as ash, and even as I watched she
crumbled and blew away. ~ Melisandre (ADWD)




This vision in the books, has been misinterpreted as Alys Karstark fleeing, was infact Arya at the end of Episode 5, when she mounts the pale mare covered in ash.








share|improve this answer















share|improve this answer




share|improve this answer








edited May 16 at 15:46









ANeves

1135 bronze badges




1135 bronze badges










answered May 15 at 6:08









KharoBangdoKharoBangdo

7,96213 gold badges47 silver badges87 bronze badges




7,96213 gold badges47 silver badges87 bronze badges










  • 4





    Did Melisandre make that prophecy in the show? I don't believe she did. In the books, she actually mistook Alys for Arya, not the other way around. It was misinterpreted, but only in the sense that she thought the girl was Arya. Books won't have the same ridiculous plot as the last few seasons, you may rest assured.

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:51











  • @Aegon i haven't read the books so I can't say. It's just a theory I came across that was relevant. That vision wasn't in the show afaik.

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 6:54






  • 2





    Well theories which are built on books material but are supposed to answer for show events are better left...on reddit I'd say. But that's of course my personal preference :)

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:59






  • 1





    @Aegon since other answers also relied on book only theories, I thought one more wouldn't harm anyone :-)

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 7:19











  • It's a parallel, to be sure.

    – Möoz
    May 15 at 9:24












  • 4





    Did Melisandre make that prophecy in the show? I don't believe she did. In the books, she actually mistook Alys for Arya, not the other way around. It was misinterpreted, but only in the sense that she thought the girl was Arya. Books won't have the same ridiculous plot as the last few seasons, you may rest assured.

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:51











  • @Aegon i haven't read the books so I can't say. It's just a theory I came across that was relevant. That vision wasn't in the show afaik.

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 6:54






  • 2





    Well theories which are built on books material but are supposed to answer for show events are better left...on reddit I'd say. But that's of course my personal preference :)

    – Aegon
    May 15 at 6:59






  • 1





    @Aegon since other answers also relied on book only theories, I thought one more wouldn't harm anyone :-)

    – KharoBangdo
    May 15 at 7:19











  • It's a parallel, to be sure.

    – Möoz
    May 15 at 9:24







4




4





Did Melisandre make that prophecy in the show? I don't believe she did. In the books, she actually mistook Alys for Arya, not the other way around. It was misinterpreted, but only in the sense that she thought the girl was Arya. Books won't have the same ridiculous plot as the last few seasons, you may rest assured.

– Aegon
May 15 at 6:51





Did Melisandre make that prophecy in the show? I don't believe she did. In the books, she actually mistook Alys for Arya, not the other way around. It was misinterpreted, but only in the sense that she thought the girl was Arya. Books won't have the same ridiculous plot as the last few seasons, you may rest assured.

– Aegon
May 15 at 6:51













@Aegon i haven't read the books so I can't say. It's just a theory I came across that was relevant. That vision wasn't in the show afaik.

– KharoBangdo
May 15 at 6:54





@Aegon i haven't read the books so I can't say. It's just a theory I came across that was relevant. That vision wasn't in the show afaik.

– KharoBangdo
May 15 at 6:54




2




2





Well theories which are built on books material but are supposed to answer for show events are better left...on reddit I'd say. But that's of course my personal preference :)

– Aegon
May 15 at 6:59





Well theories which are built on books material but are supposed to answer for show events are better left...on reddit I'd say. But that's of course my personal preference :)

– Aegon
May 15 at 6:59




1




1





@Aegon since other answers also relied on book only theories, I thought one more wouldn't harm anyone :-)

– KharoBangdo
May 15 at 7:19





@Aegon since other answers also relied on book only theories, I thought one more wouldn't harm anyone :-)

– KharoBangdo
May 15 at 7:19













It's a parallel, to be sure.

– Möoz
May 15 at 9:24





It's a parallel, to be sure.

– Möoz
May 15 at 9:24











7


















Fact: It is symbolic of her hope and new mission

The horse appearing, against all odds, at the most opportune time and ready to carry her, is a symbol of a new beginning.



Whether it's the beginning of a new mission to assassinate Daenerys for what she did, or a mission to escape and find solace is yet to be determined.



Possibility: It is a symbol of the 'Pale Mare' prophecy

Daenerys had a prophecy (in the books) where a 'Pale Mare' would come forth, carrying death towards her. This hasn't been payed out in the show (and I'm not sure it was alluded to), but it certainly is a potential symbol.



In the books, the 'Pale Mare' carried a deadly flu (as mentioned in StarHawk's answer); in this case, it would be carrying Arya, the personification of death.



Improbability: It is Dany's own horse, her beloved 'Silver'

In my mind, it is Daenerys' own horse 'The Silver'. It's so pissed off about what Dany did, that it decided to leave and go over to Arya.






share|improve this answer


























  • Didn't Silver die a few seasons ago?

    – berry120
    May 16 at 0:16











  • @berry120 You're right it did.

    – Möoz
    May 16 at 0:19






  • 3





    Plot-twistability: the horse is dead, just like Arya is also dead. She just happens to be able to wander among the living because the NK touched her in 8x3.

    – walen
    May 16 at 8:05







  • 1





    @walen I like it, but it's too deep for this show :-p

    – Möoz
    May 16 at 22:08















7


















Fact: It is symbolic of her hope and new mission

The horse appearing, against all odds, at the most opportune time and ready to carry her, is a symbol of a new beginning.



Whether it's the beginning of a new mission to assassinate Daenerys for what she did, or a mission to escape and find solace is yet to be determined.



Possibility: It is a symbol of the 'Pale Mare' prophecy

Daenerys had a prophecy (in the books) where a 'Pale Mare' would come forth, carrying death towards her. This hasn't been payed out in the show (and I'm not sure it was alluded to), but it certainly is a potential symbol.



In the books, the 'Pale Mare' carried a deadly flu (as mentioned in StarHawk's answer); in this case, it would be carrying Arya, the personification of death.



Improbability: It is Dany's own horse, her beloved 'Silver'

In my mind, it is Daenerys' own horse 'The Silver'. It's so pissed off about what Dany did, that it decided to leave and go over to Arya.






share|improve this answer


























  • Didn't Silver die a few seasons ago?

    – berry120
    May 16 at 0:16











  • @berry120 You're right it did.

    – Möoz
    May 16 at 0:19






  • 3





    Plot-twistability: the horse is dead, just like Arya is also dead. She just happens to be able to wander among the living because the NK touched her in 8x3.

    – walen
    May 16 at 8:05







  • 1





    @walen I like it, but it's too deep for this show :-p

    – Möoz
    May 16 at 22:08













7














7










7









Fact: It is symbolic of her hope and new mission

The horse appearing, against all odds, at the most opportune time and ready to carry her, is a symbol of a new beginning.



Whether it's the beginning of a new mission to assassinate Daenerys for what she did, or a mission to escape and find solace is yet to be determined.



Possibility: It is a symbol of the 'Pale Mare' prophecy

Daenerys had a prophecy (in the books) where a 'Pale Mare' would come forth, carrying death towards her. This hasn't been payed out in the show (and I'm not sure it was alluded to), but it certainly is a potential symbol.



In the books, the 'Pale Mare' carried a deadly flu (as mentioned in StarHawk's answer); in this case, it would be carrying Arya, the personification of death.



Improbability: It is Dany's own horse, her beloved 'Silver'

In my mind, it is Daenerys' own horse 'The Silver'. It's so pissed off about what Dany did, that it decided to leave and go over to Arya.






share|improve this answer














Fact: It is symbolic of her hope and new mission

The horse appearing, against all odds, at the most opportune time and ready to carry her, is a symbol of a new beginning.



Whether it's the beginning of a new mission to assassinate Daenerys for what she did, or a mission to escape and find solace is yet to be determined.



Possibility: It is a symbol of the 'Pale Mare' prophecy

Daenerys had a prophecy (in the books) where a 'Pale Mare' would come forth, carrying death towards her. This hasn't been payed out in the show (and I'm not sure it was alluded to), but it certainly is a potential symbol.



In the books, the 'Pale Mare' carried a deadly flu (as mentioned in StarHawk's answer); in this case, it would be carrying Arya, the personification of death.



Improbability: It is Dany's own horse, her beloved 'Silver'

In my mind, it is Daenerys' own horse 'The Silver'. It's so pissed off about what Dany did, that it decided to leave and go over to Arya.







share|improve this answer













share|improve this answer




share|improve this answer










answered May 15 at 0:32









MöozMöoz

34.3k27 gold badges226 silver badges387 bronze badges




34.3k27 gold badges226 silver badges387 bronze badges















  • Didn't Silver die a few seasons ago?

    – berry120
    May 16 at 0:16











  • @berry120 You're right it did.

    – Möoz
    May 16 at 0:19






  • 3





    Plot-twistability: the horse is dead, just like Arya is also dead. She just happens to be able to wander among the living because the NK touched her in 8x3.

    – walen
    May 16 at 8:05







  • 1





    @walen I like it, but it's too deep for this show :-p

    – Möoz
    May 16 at 22:08

















  • Didn't Silver die a few seasons ago?

    – berry120
    May 16 at 0:16











  • @berry120 You're right it did.

    – Möoz
    May 16 at 0:19






  • 3





    Plot-twistability: the horse is dead, just like Arya is also dead. She just happens to be able to wander among the living because the NK touched her in 8x3.

    – walen
    May 16 at 8:05







  • 1





    @walen I like it, but it's too deep for this show :-p

    – Möoz
    May 16 at 22:08
















Didn't Silver die a few seasons ago?

– berry120
May 16 at 0:16





Didn't Silver die a few seasons ago?

– berry120
May 16 at 0:16













@berry120 You're right it did.

– Möoz
May 16 at 0:19





@berry120 You're right it did.

– Möoz
May 16 at 0:19




3




3





Plot-twistability: the horse is dead, just like Arya is also dead. She just happens to be able to wander among the living because the NK touched her in 8x3.

– walen
May 16 at 8:05






Plot-twistability: the horse is dead, just like Arya is also dead. She just happens to be able to wander among the living because the NK touched her in 8x3.

– walen
May 16 at 8:05





1




1





@walen I like it, but it's too deep for this show :-p

– Möoz
May 16 at 22:08





@walen I like it, but it's too deep for this show :-p

– Möoz
May 16 at 22:08











1


















I have come across two explanations for the horse appearing for Arya:



  1. Shadowfax is taking her to heal at the house of Elrond


  2. Bran rescuing her via warg






share|improve this answer





















  • 10





    This would be better if you kept the LOTR joke answer out of it and instead focused on the Bran warging to rescue her.

    – TheLethalCarrot
    May 15 at 13:36






  • 4





    @TheLethalCarrot Problem is either option seems equally likely at this point.

    – The Head Rush
    May 15 at 17:10






  • 1





    @TheLethalCarrot D&D will clumsily christen that horse "Shadowwolf"... mark my words!

    – Mateen Ulhaq
    May 16 at 23:24















1


















I have come across two explanations for the horse appearing for Arya:



  1. Shadowfax is taking her to heal at the house of Elrond


  2. Bran rescuing her via warg






share|improve this answer





















  • 10





    This would be better if you kept the LOTR joke answer out of it and instead focused on the Bran warging to rescue her.

    – TheLethalCarrot
    May 15 at 13:36






  • 4





    @TheLethalCarrot Problem is either option seems equally likely at this point.

    – The Head Rush
    May 15 at 17:10






  • 1





    @TheLethalCarrot D&D will clumsily christen that horse "Shadowwolf"... mark my words!

    – Mateen Ulhaq
    May 16 at 23:24













1














1










1









I have come across two explanations for the horse appearing for Arya:



  1. Shadowfax is taking her to heal at the house of Elrond


  2. Bran rescuing her via warg






share|improve this answer














I have come across two explanations for the horse appearing for Arya:



  1. Shadowfax is taking her to heal at the house of Elrond


  2. Bran rescuing her via warg







share|improve this answer













share|improve this answer




share|improve this answer










answered May 15 at 13:34









WhatEvaWhatEva

392 bronze badges




392 bronze badges










  • 10





    This would be better if you kept the LOTR joke answer out of it and instead focused on the Bran warging to rescue her.

    – TheLethalCarrot
    May 15 at 13:36






  • 4





    @TheLethalCarrot Problem is either option seems equally likely at this point.

    – The Head Rush
    May 15 at 17:10






  • 1





    @TheLethalCarrot D&D will clumsily christen that horse "Shadowwolf"... mark my words!

    – Mateen Ulhaq
    May 16 at 23:24












  • 10





    This would be better if you kept the LOTR joke answer out of it and instead focused on the Bran warging to rescue her.

    – TheLethalCarrot
    May 15 at 13:36






  • 4





    @TheLethalCarrot Problem is either option seems equally likely at this point.

    – The Head Rush
    May 15 at 17:10






  • 1





    @TheLethalCarrot D&D will clumsily christen that horse "Shadowwolf"... mark my words!

    – Mateen Ulhaq
    May 16 at 23:24







10




10





This would be better if you kept the LOTR joke answer out of it and instead focused on the Bran warging to rescue her.

– TheLethalCarrot
May 15 at 13:36





This would be better if you kept the LOTR joke answer out of it and instead focused on the Bran warging to rescue her.

– TheLethalCarrot
May 15 at 13:36




4




4





@TheLethalCarrot Problem is either option seems equally likely at this point.

– The Head Rush
May 15 at 17:10





@TheLethalCarrot Problem is either option seems equally likely at this point.

– The Head Rush
May 15 at 17:10




1




1





@TheLethalCarrot D&D will clumsily christen that horse "Shadowwolf"... mark my words!

– Mateen Ulhaq
May 16 at 23:24





@TheLethalCarrot D&D will clumsily christen that horse "Shadowwolf"... mark my words!

– Mateen Ulhaq
May 16 at 23:24











0


















Probably not, or there's at least no evidence suggesting it.



Thematically, a white horse means plague. The Pale Mare is the epithet of a disease known as the Bloody Flux, which appears in the books but not in the show.



If we abandon fantastic conspiracy theories with no evidence, then there's this:



Horses tend to panic when they smell smoke or get exposed to flames. Or dragons, presumably. So one can perhaps assume that this is a combat trained horse.



There is a commander of the Golden Company riding a white horse earlier in the same episode. He is in fact the only defender on horse, so it is probably his horse.



Or it could have belonged to a fallen dothraki.






share|improve this answer


























  • Looking at the pattern on it's muzzle I think the two horses are being played by the same actor. They also have the same bridle. But I don't think they're supposed to be the same horse because there is also a shot of Strickland's horse lying dead in the mud.

    – Oscar Cunningham
    May 15 at 18:20






  • 1





    @OscarCunningham Arya's found horse looks a bit bruised up though. Are you sure the first white horse actually died and didn't just get knocked out? :)

    – Amarth
    May 16 at 15:44















0


















Probably not, or there's at least no evidence suggesting it.



Thematically, a white horse means plague. The Pale Mare is the epithet of a disease known as the Bloody Flux, which appears in the books but not in the show.



If we abandon fantastic conspiracy theories with no evidence, then there's this:



Horses tend to panic when they smell smoke or get exposed to flames. Or dragons, presumably. So one can perhaps assume that this is a combat trained horse.



There is a commander of the Golden Company riding a white horse earlier in the same episode. He is in fact the only defender on horse, so it is probably his horse.



Or it could have belonged to a fallen dothraki.






share|improve this answer


























  • Looking at the pattern on it's muzzle I think the two horses are being played by the same actor. They also have the same bridle. But I don't think they're supposed to be the same horse because there is also a shot of Strickland's horse lying dead in the mud.

    – Oscar Cunningham
    May 15 at 18:20






  • 1





    @OscarCunningham Arya's found horse looks a bit bruised up though. Are you sure the first white horse actually died and didn't just get knocked out? :)

    – Amarth
    May 16 at 15:44













0














0










0









Probably not, or there's at least no evidence suggesting it.



Thematically, a white horse means plague. The Pale Mare is the epithet of a disease known as the Bloody Flux, which appears in the books but not in the show.



If we abandon fantastic conspiracy theories with no evidence, then there's this:



Horses tend to panic when they smell smoke or get exposed to flames. Or dragons, presumably. So one can perhaps assume that this is a combat trained horse.



There is a commander of the Golden Company riding a white horse earlier in the same episode. He is in fact the only defender on horse, so it is probably his horse.



Or it could have belonged to a fallen dothraki.






share|improve this answer














Probably not, or there's at least no evidence suggesting it.



Thematically, a white horse means plague. The Pale Mare is the epithet of a disease known as the Bloody Flux, which appears in the books but not in the show.



If we abandon fantastic conspiracy theories with no evidence, then there's this:



Horses tend to panic when they smell smoke or get exposed to flames. Or dragons, presumably. So one can perhaps assume that this is a combat trained horse.



There is a commander of the Golden Company riding a white horse earlier in the same episode. He is in fact the only defender on horse, so it is probably his horse.



Or it could have belonged to a fallen dothraki.







share|improve this answer













share|improve this answer




share|improve this answer










answered May 15 at 16:43









AmarthAmarth

2,3712 silver badges20 bronze badges




2,3712 silver badges20 bronze badges















  • Looking at the pattern on it's muzzle I think the two horses are being played by the same actor. They also have the same bridle. But I don't think they're supposed to be the same horse because there is also a shot of Strickland's horse lying dead in the mud.

    – Oscar Cunningham
    May 15 at 18:20






  • 1





    @OscarCunningham Arya's found horse looks a bit bruised up though. Are you sure the first white horse actually died and didn't just get knocked out? :)

    – Amarth
    May 16 at 15:44

















  • Looking at the pattern on it's muzzle I think the two horses are being played by the same actor. They also have the same bridle. But I don't think they're supposed to be the same horse because there is also a shot of Strickland's horse lying dead in the mud.

    – Oscar Cunningham
    May 15 at 18:20






  • 1





    @OscarCunningham Arya's found horse looks a bit bruised up though. Are you sure the first white horse actually died and didn't just get knocked out? :)

    – Amarth
    May 16 at 15:44
















Looking at the pattern on it's muzzle I think the two horses are being played by the same actor. They also have the same bridle. But I don't think they're supposed to be the same horse because there is also a shot of Strickland's horse lying dead in the mud.

– Oscar Cunningham
May 15 at 18:20





Looking at the pattern on it's muzzle I think the two horses are being played by the same actor. They also have the same bridle. But I don't think they're supposed to be the same horse because there is also a shot of Strickland's horse lying dead in the mud.

– Oscar Cunningham
May 15 at 18:20




1




1





@OscarCunningham Arya's found horse looks a bit bruised up though. Are you sure the first white horse actually died and didn't just get knocked out? :)

– Amarth
May 16 at 15:44





@OscarCunningham Arya's found horse looks a bit bruised up though. Are you sure the first white horse actually died and didn't just get knocked out? :)

– Amarth
May 16 at 15:44





protected by Aegon May 16 at 14:53



Thank you for your interest in this question.
Because it has attracted low-quality or spam answers that had to be removed, posting an answer now requires 10 reputation on this site (the association bonus does not count).



Would you like to answer one of these unanswered questions instead?



Popular posts from this blog

Distance measures on a map of a game The 2019 Stack Overflow Developer Survey Results Are Inmin distance in a graphShortest distance path on contour plotHow to plot a tilted map?Finding points outside of a diskDelaunay link distanceAnnulus from GeoDisks: drawing a ring on a mapNegative Correlation DistanceFind distance along a path (GPS coordinates)Finding position at given distance in a GeoPathMathematics behind distance estimation using camera

How to get a smooth, uniform ParametricPlot of a 2D Region?How to plot a complicated Region?How to exclude a region from ParametricPlotHow discretize a region placing vertices on a specific non-uniform gridHow to transform a Plot or a ParametricPlot into a RegionHow can I get a smooth plot of a bounded region?Smooth ParametricPlot3D with RegionFunction?Smooth border of a region ParametricPlotSmooth region boundarySmooth region plot from list of pointsGet minimum y of a certain x in a region

Genealogie vun de Merowenger Vum Merowech bis zum Chilperich I. | Navigatiounsmenü