Has the Hulk always been able to talk?Why did The Hulk punch Thor while fighting the Chitauri?Why has the role of Bruce Banner been played by different actors in the three films that Hulk has appeared in?How did The Hulk end up in India?Is Hulk in The Avengers the same Hulk from The Incredible Hulk?What is the reason the Hulk (Bruce Banner) says he is always angry in The Avengers?Why Lash has been killing Inhumans?How was Hulk able to speak fluently in Thor Ragnarok?Is Iron Man stronger than the Hulk?How was Thanos able to destroy the Infinity Stones?
Dynamics using m, r, s, and z. What do they mean?
Why exactly is the answer 50 ohms?
How to respond to "Why didn't you do a postdoc after your PhD?"
Why does Sonny say they call Michael "Giogali"?
Anatomically Correct Baku
'provocative' vs 'sexy'
3-prong to 4-prong conversion - EXTRA MISLABELLED WIRES - Dryer cable upgrade and installation
Can't use bars | | in nomenclature package
Translate "Everything burns" into classical Latin
What does "inet" stand for in the ip utility?
What is the name for a fluid transition between two tones? When did it first appear?
A fast aquatic predator with multiple eyes and pupils. Would these eyes be possible?
Does almost every point in Euclidean space have unique projection on any given set?
Why is beatboxing called 「ヒューマンビートボックス」?
Can digital computers understand infinity?
How can I add a recepticle to this junction box full of push splices?
Why does Chinuch confuse Parashat Nitzavim and Vayelech?
Does an excessive table violate normalization rules?
Can there be an atomic nucleus where there are more protons than neutrons?
What‘s wrong with my proof of the Law of Total Variance?
Are Snap and Flatpack apps safe to install? Are they "official", approved or tested for a particular distro version?
Is "Volume of Solids of Revolution" a part of Cal I or Cac II
SSD or HDD for server
"inuendo" in a piano score
Has the Hulk always been able to talk?
Why did The Hulk punch Thor while fighting the Chitauri?Why has the role of Bruce Banner been played by different actors in the three films that Hulk has appeared in?How did The Hulk end up in India?Is Hulk in The Avengers the same Hulk from The Incredible Hulk?What is the reason the Hulk (Bruce Banner) says he is always angry in The Avengers?Why Lash has been killing Inhumans?How was Hulk able to speak fluently in Thor Ragnarok?Is Iron Man stronger than the Hulk?How was Thanos able to destroy the Infinity Stones?
.everyoneloves__top-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__mid-leaderboard:empty,.everyoneloves__bot-mid-leaderboard:empty
margin-bottom:0;
In Thor: Ragnarok Hulk has taken full control, Banner states that usually, he feels like he's got a hand on the wheel but this time he had no awareness of what was happening. So Hulk did seem to become stronger mentally and take fuller control. This leads to Hulk talking.
Before that, we never saw Hulk talking, until Avengers: Endgame Banner again tests with Gamma radiation and end up becoming Professor Hulk.
But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the The Avengers (2012).
So is Hulk able to speak all the time and did he hide this from other Avengers?
marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-endgame the-avengers thor-ragnarok
add a comment
|
In Thor: Ragnarok Hulk has taken full control, Banner states that usually, he feels like he's got a hand on the wheel but this time he had no awareness of what was happening. So Hulk did seem to become stronger mentally and take fuller control. This leads to Hulk talking.
Before that, we never saw Hulk talking, until Avengers: Endgame Banner again tests with Gamma radiation and end up becoming Professor Hulk.
But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the The Avengers (2012).
So is Hulk able to speak all the time and did he hide this from other Avengers?
marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-endgame the-avengers thor-ragnarok
add a comment
|
In Thor: Ragnarok Hulk has taken full control, Banner states that usually, he feels like he's got a hand on the wheel but this time he had no awareness of what was happening. So Hulk did seem to become stronger mentally and take fuller control. This leads to Hulk talking.
Before that, we never saw Hulk talking, until Avengers: Endgame Banner again tests with Gamma radiation and end up becoming Professor Hulk.
But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the The Avengers (2012).
So is Hulk able to speak all the time and did he hide this from other Avengers?
marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-endgame the-avengers thor-ragnarok
In Thor: Ragnarok Hulk has taken full control, Banner states that usually, he feels like he's got a hand on the wheel but this time he had no awareness of what was happening. So Hulk did seem to become stronger mentally and take fuller control. This leads to Hulk talking.
Before that, we never saw Hulk talking, until Avengers: Endgame Banner again tests with Gamma radiation and end up becoming Professor Hulk.
But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the The Avengers (2012).
So is Hulk able to speak all the time and did he hide this from other Avengers?
marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-endgame the-avengers thor-ragnarok
marvel-cinematic-universe avengers-endgame the-avengers thor-ragnarok
edited May 2 at 21:02
Napoleon Wilson♦
43.6k46 gold badges289 silver badges555 bronze badges
43.6k46 gold badges289 silver badges555 bronze badges
asked May 2 at 11:59
ashikashik
1,6212 gold badges14 silver badges27 bronze badges
1,6212 gold badges14 silver badges27 bronze badges
add a comment
|
add a comment
|
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie.
Yes
It's established that the Hulk can talk coherently provided he's not in complete "rage" mode during, say, battle.
When he bashes Loki he clearly says:
Puny God
17
Plus, as we learn in Endgame, he also said “So many stairs!” during the events of The Avengers.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 13:46
27
@PaulD.Waite OP is basically asking if Hulk being able to talk during that time period was retconned by Endgame, so that isn't a valid point.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 14:14
7
@CaptainMan So what? It's still the same time period and so it's the same version of the hulk.
– Todd Sewell
May 2 at 14:30
4
Oh yeah sorry, I didn’t spot that the OP mentioned that in their question.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 14:36
9
@ToddSewell When OP says "But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie." it is clear they are saying Hulk didn't talk in The Avengers (2012 film) (though they are remembering incorrectly as shown in this answer) but did talk in Endgame during the 'flashback'. OP is just confused if Hulk was always able to or if it was retconned.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 20:12
add a comment
|
He spoke in the 2008 movie The Incredible Hulk
Leave me alone
Source
4
There's also a TVTrope for HulkSpeak - whether this is "official" or not is debatable, but it does prove the general notion that Hulk has the power of speech.
– Snow
May 2 at 13:25
22
@Jenayah Why does everyone seem to think this? No, The Incredible Hulk was always part of the MCU. There's an end credits scene with Tony Stark and everything. It's just as much a part of the MCU as every other MCU movie. (It's also pretty underrated, if you ask me. Certainly better than, say, Thor: The Dark World.)
– only_pro
May 2 at 14:02
5
It doesn't have sequels because Universal still has rights to solo Hulk movies.
– pboss3010
May 2 at 14:26
11
He also says "Hulk SMASH!" during his battle with Abomination.
– aleppke
May 2 at 15:00
9
@aleppke I'm pretty sure that every on-screen iteration of the Hulk has been able to deliver an occasional "Hulk SMASH!", even going back to the old TV show.
– Darrel Hoffman
May 2 at 17:22
|
show 9 more comments
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
2 Answers
2
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie.
Yes
It's established that the Hulk can talk coherently provided he's not in complete "rage" mode during, say, battle.
When he bashes Loki he clearly says:
Puny God
17
Plus, as we learn in Endgame, he also said “So many stairs!” during the events of The Avengers.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 13:46
27
@PaulD.Waite OP is basically asking if Hulk being able to talk during that time period was retconned by Endgame, so that isn't a valid point.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 14:14
7
@CaptainMan So what? It's still the same time period and so it's the same version of the hulk.
– Todd Sewell
May 2 at 14:30
4
Oh yeah sorry, I didn’t spot that the OP mentioned that in their question.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 14:36
9
@ToddSewell When OP says "But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie." it is clear they are saying Hulk didn't talk in The Avengers (2012 film) (though they are remembering incorrectly as shown in this answer) but did talk in Endgame during the 'flashback'. OP is just confused if Hulk was always able to or if it was retconned.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 20:12
add a comment
|
But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie.
Yes
It's established that the Hulk can talk coherently provided he's not in complete "rage" mode during, say, battle.
When he bashes Loki he clearly says:
Puny God
17
Plus, as we learn in Endgame, he also said “So many stairs!” during the events of The Avengers.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 13:46
27
@PaulD.Waite OP is basically asking if Hulk being able to talk during that time period was retconned by Endgame, so that isn't a valid point.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 14:14
7
@CaptainMan So what? It's still the same time period and so it's the same version of the hulk.
– Todd Sewell
May 2 at 14:30
4
Oh yeah sorry, I didn’t spot that the OP mentioned that in their question.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 14:36
9
@ToddSewell When OP says "But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie." it is clear they are saying Hulk didn't talk in The Avengers (2012 film) (though they are remembering incorrectly as shown in this answer) but did talk in Endgame during the 'flashback'. OP is just confused if Hulk was always able to or if it was retconned.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 20:12
add a comment
|
But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie.
Yes
It's established that the Hulk can talk coherently provided he's not in complete "rage" mode during, say, battle.
When he bashes Loki he clearly says:
Puny God
But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie.
Yes
It's established that the Hulk can talk coherently provided he's not in complete "rage" mode during, say, battle.
When he bashes Loki he clearly says:
Puny God
answered May 2 at 12:09
Paulie_DPaulie_D
102k19 gold badges383 silver badges342 bronze badges
102k19 gold badges383 silver badges342 bronze badges
17
Plus, as we learn in Endgame, he also said “So many stairs!” during the events of The Avengers.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 13:46
27
@PaulD.Waite OP is basically asking if Hulk being able to talk during that time period was retconned by Endgame, so that isn't a valid point.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 14:14
7
@CaptainMan So what? It's still the same time period and so it's the same version of the hulk.
– Todd Sewell
May 2 at 14:30
4
Oh yeah sorry, I didn’t spot that the OP mentioned that in their question.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 14:36
9
@ToddSewell When OP says "But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie." it is clear they are saying Hulk didn't talk in The Avengers (2012 film) (though they are remembering incorrectly as shown in this answer) but did talk in Endgame during the 'flashback'. OP is just confused if Hulk was always able to or if it was retconned.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 20:12
add a comment
|
17
Plus, as we learn in Endgame, he also said “So many stairs!” during the events of The Avengers.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 13:46
27
@PaulD.Waite OP is basically asking if Hulk being able to talk during that time period was retconned by Endgame, so that isn't a valid point.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 14:14
7
@CaptainMan So what? It's still the same time period and so it's the same version of the hulk.
– Todd Sewell
May 2 at 14:30
4
Oh yeah sorry, I didn’t spot that the OP mentioned that in their question.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 14:36
9
@ToddSewell When OP says "But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie." it is clear they are saying Hulk didn't talk in The Avengers (2012 film) (though they are remembering incorrectly as shown in this answer) but did talk in Endgame during the 'flashback'. OP is just confused if Hulk was always able to or if it was retconned.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 20:12
17
17
Plus, as we learn in Endgame, he also said “So many stairs!” during the events of The Avengers.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 13:46
Plus, as we learn in Endgame, he also said “So many stairs!” during the events of The Avengers.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 13:46
27
27
@PaulD.Waite OP is basically asking if Hulk being able to talk during that time period was retconned by Endgame, so that isn't a valid point.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 14:14
@PaulD.Waite OP is basically asking if Hulk being able to talk during that time period was retconned by Endgame, so that isn't a valid point.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 14:14
7
7
@CaptainMan So what? It's still the same time period and so it's the same version of the hulk.
– Todd Sewell
May 2 at 14:30
@CaptainMan So what? It's still the same time period and so it's the same version of the hulk.
– Todd Sewell
May 2 at 14:30
4
4
Oh yeah sorry, I didn’t spot that the OP mentioned that in their question.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 14:36
Oh yeah sorry, I didn’t spot that the OP mentioned that in their question.
– Paul D. Waite
May 2 at 14:36
9
9
@ToddSewell When OP says "But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie." it is clear they are saying Hulk didn't talk in The Avengers (2012 film) (though they are remembering incorrectly as shown in this answer) but did talk in Endgame during the 'flashback'. OP is just confused if Hulk was always able to or if it was retconned.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 20:12
@ToddSewell When OP says "But in Endgame when the heroes traveled back in time to get the Infinity Stones, at the events of The Avengers (2012 film), we see that Hulk from that time period talking. Which was never shown in the Avengers movie." it is clear they are saying Hulk didn't talk in The Avengers (2012 film) (though they are remembering incorrectly as shown in this answer) but did talk in Endgame during the 'flashback'. OP is just confused if Hulk was always able to or if it was retconned.
– Captain Man
May 2 at 20:12
add a comment
|
He spoke in the 2008 movie The Incredible Hulk
Leave me alone
Source
4
There's also a TVTrope for HulkSpeak - whether this is "official" or not is debatable, but it does prove the general notion that Hulk has the power of speech.
– Snow
May 2 at 13:25
22
@Jenayah Why does everyone seem to think this? No, The Incredible Hulk was always part of the MCU. There's an end credits scene with Tony Stark and everything. It's just as much a part of the MCU as every other MCU movie. (It's also pretty underrated, if you ask me. Certainly better than, say, Thor: The Dark World.)
– only_pro
May 2 at 14:02
5
It doesn't have sequels because Universal still has rights to solo Hulk movies.
– pboss3010
May 2 at 14:26
11
He also says "Hulk SMASH!" during his battle with Abomination.
– aleppke
May 2 at 15:00
9
@aleppke I'm pretty sure that every on-screen iteration of the Hulk has been able to deliver an occasional "Hulk SMASH!", even going back to the old TV show.
– Darrel Hoffman
May 2 at 17:22
|
show 9 more comments
He spoke in the 2008 movie The Incredible Hulk
Leave me alone
Source
4
There's also a TVTrope for HulkSpeak - whether this is "official" or not is debatable, but it does prove the general notion that Hulk has the power of speech.
– Snow
May 2 at 13:25
22
@Jenayah Why does everyone seem to think this? No, The Incredible Hulk was always part of the MCU. There's an end credits scene with Tony Stark and everything. It's just as much a part of the MCU as every other MCU movie. (It's also pretty underrated, if you ask me. Certainly better than, say, Thor: The Dark World.)
– only_pro
May 2 at 14:02
5
It doesn't have sequels because Universal still has rights to solo Hulk movies.
– pboss3010
May 2 at 14:26
11
He also says "Hulk SMASH!" during his battle with Abomination.
– aleppke
May 2 at 15:00
9
@aleppke I'm pretty sure that every on-screen iteration of the Hulk has been able to deliver an occasional "Hulk SMASH!", even going back to the old TV show.
– Darrel Hoffman
May 2 at 17:22
|
show 9 more comments
He spoke in the 2008 movie The Incredible Hulk
Leave me alone
Source
He spoke in the 2008 movie The Incredible Hulk
Leave me alone
Source
answered May 2 at 12:24
SnowSnow
11.7k2 gold badges42 silver badges50 bronze badges
11.7k2 gold badges42 silver badges50 bronze badges
4
There's also a TVTrope for HulkSpeak - whether this is "official" or not is debatable, but it does prove the general notion that Hulk has the power of speech.
– Snow
May 2 at 13:25
22
@Jenayah Why does everyone seem to think this? No, The Incredible Hulk was always part of the MCU. There's an end credits scene with Tony Stark and everything. It's just as much a part of the MCU as every other MCU movie. (It's also pretty underrated, if you ask me. Certainly better than, say, Thor: The Dark World.)
– only_pro
May 2 at 14:02
5
It doesn't have sequels because Universal still has rights to solo Hulk movies.
– pboss3010
May 2 at 14:26
11
He also says "Hulk SMASH!" during his battle with Abomination.
– aleppke
May 2 at 15:00
9
@aleppke I'm pretty sure that every on-screen iteration of the Hulk has been able to deliver an occasional "Hulk SMASH!", even going back to the old TV show.
– Darrel Hoffman
May 2 at 17:22
|
show 9 more comments
4
There's also a TVTrope for HulkSpeak - whether this is "official" or not is debatable, but it does prove the general notion that Hulk has the power of speech.
– Snow
May 2 at 13:25
22
@Jenayah Why does everyone seem to think this? No, The Incredible Hulk was always part of the MCU. There's an end credits scene with Tony Stark and everything. It's just as much a part of the MCU as every other MCU movie. (It's also pretty underrated, if you ask me. Certainly better than, say, Thor: The Dark World.)
– only_pro
May 2 at 14:02
5
It doesn't have sequels because Universal still has rights to solo Hulk movies.
– pboss3010
May 2 at 14:26
11
He also says "Hulk SMASH!" during his battle with Abomination.
– aleppke
May 2 at 15:00
9
@aleppke I'm pretty sure that every on-screen iteration of the Hulk has been able to deliver an occasional "Hulk SMASH!", even going back to the old TV show.
– Darrel Hoffman
May 2 at 17:22
4
4
There's also a TVTrope for HulkSpeak - whether this is "official" or not is debatable, but it does prove the general notion that Hulk has the power of speech.
– Snow
May 2 at 13:25
There's also a TVTrope for HulkSpeak - whether this is "official" or not is debatable, but it does prove the general notion that Hulk has the power of speech.
– Snow
May 2 at 13:25
22
22
@Jenayah Why does everyone seem to think this? No, The Incredible Hulk was always part of the MCU. There's an end credits scene with Tony Stark and everything. It's just as much a part of the MCU as every other MCU movie. (It's also pretty underrated, if you ask me. Certainly better than, say, Thor: The Dark World.)
– only_pro
May 2 at 14:02
@Jenayah Why does everyone seem to think this? No, The Incredible Hulk was always part of the MCU. There's an end credits scene with Tony Stark and everything. It's just as much a part of the MCU as every other MCU movie. (It's also pretty underrated, if you ask me. Certainly better than, say, Thor: The Dark World.)
– only_pro
May 2 at 14:02
5
5
It doesn't have sequels because Universal still has rights to solo Hulk movies.
– pboss3010
May 2 at 14:26
It doesn't have sequels because Universal still has rights to solo Hulk movies.
– pboss3010
May 2 at 14:26
11
11
He also says "Hulk SMASH!" during his battle with Abomination.
– aleppke
May 2 at 15:00
He also says "Hulk SMASH!" during his battle with Abomination.
– aleppke
May 2 at 15:00
9
9
@aleppke I'm pretty sure that every on-screen iteration of the Hulk has been able to deliver an occasional "Hulk SMASH!", even going back to the old TV show.
– Darrel Hoffman
May 2 at 17:22
@aleppke I'm pretty sure that every on-screen iteration of the Hulk has been able to deliver an occasional "Hulk SMASH!", even going back to the old TV show.
– Darrel Hoffman
May 2 at 17:22
|
show 9 more comments